The Chicago Cubs are facing important challenges after pitcher Shota Imanaga suffered a hamstring injury in May 2024, just as the team was gaining momentum. This development created uncertainty within the pitching rotation and forced the front office to rethink its roster management approach, balancing immediate needs with player health. The issue is particularly pressing as the Cubs, leading the NL Central, weigh how best to reintroduce Imanaga without disrupting the team’s rhythm.
Before his injury, Imanaga showed impressive form with a 2.82 ERA over 44⅔ innings. Although sidelined, this break from pitching is seen as a chance to preserve his long-term performance, especially as the Cubs prepare for a crucial postseason stretch. Manager Craig Counsell highlighted how other players have stepped up in Imanaga’s absence, noting the challenges that lie ahead as Imanaga works back into shape.
We have pitched well in his absence,
—Craig Counsell, Cubs Manager
I would rather have Sho out there… but this is the result of other players stepping up… He’s gotten a break—it wasn’t an arm injury… but he’s going to have challenges coming back that maybe he wouldn’t have had if he was pitching on a regular basis.
—Craig Counsell, Cubs Manager
Rotation Holds Steady Despite Imanaga’s Absence
The Cubs’ pitching staff has maintained stability while Imanaga recovers, with key contributors filling the void effectively. Jameson Taillon, boasting a 3.84 ERA and a 1.04 WHIP, along with Matthew Boyd, who holds a 2.79 ERA and 1.17 WHIP, have provided consistent performances that keep the team competitive. Although Ben Brown has struggled with a 5.57 ERA, the overall rotation has managed to sustain the Cubs’ strong standing atop their division.
This resilience means Imanaga’s return may boost the rotation without being an immediate necessity to hold the NL Central lead by 5.5 games and maintain a +106 run differential. Nonetheless, reintegrating him requires caution, as the transition from rehab outings in Triple-A to the speed of Major League Baseball presents risks. Manager Counsell plans to evaluate Imanaga’s readiness following his upcoming rehab start before making roster moves.
We just want to evaluate Friday’s start and go from there,
—Craig Counsell, Cubs Manager
Key Roster Decisions Loom as Postseason Approaches
The Cubs now face a critical choice: maintain the current rotation that has proven capable or reinstate Imanaga and adjust roles once more. With the postseason on the horizon, this decision carries immense weight, as every roster move could impact the team’s chances in October. Imanaga’s eventual comeback could reshape the pitching staff, but the front office must prioritize long-term health and team chemistry while navigating pressures from the playoff chase.
Pete Crow-Armstrong Opts Out of Home Run Derby Amid MVP-Caliber Season
Alongside Imanaga’s injury story, another Cubs star is making headlines for different reasons. Outfielder Pete Crow-Armstrong, who has emerged as a critical offensive force, has declined an invitation to this year’s Home Run Derby despite his MVP-caliber performance. Crow-Armstrong, 22, leads the team with 20 home runs and ranks seventh across Major League Baseball. His contributions have helped solidify the Cubs’ position as division leaders.
Before launching a 452-foot home run against the Milwaukee Brewers, Crow-Armstrong confirmed his decision to skip the Derby, citing the unique demands of the event compared to his usual batting style. He explained his concerns about stamina during the timed competition and humorously addressed his own limitations with power hitting.
That’s a different kind of power,
—Pete Crow-Armstrong, Cubs Outfielder
I don’t know if I can withstand however long the timer is there. That’d be a struggle.
—Pete Crow-Armstrong, Cubs Outfielder
(Batting practice) pop is a different kind of pop. I don’t got it like that.
—Pete Crow-Armstrong, Cubs Outfielder
Although fans may feel disappointed by Crow-Armstrong’s absence from the Derby spectacle, this choice highlights his maturity in managing his abilities and focusing on consistent team success. His decision aligns with the Cubs’ broader strategy of safeguarding key players’ health for the crucial stretch ahead.
Crow-Armstrong Eyes All-Star Game as He Leads Fan Voting
Despite skipping the Derby, Crow-Armstrong remains a fan favorite and is currently leading NL outfielders in fan votes for the All-Star Game. His 2025 season has exceeded expectations, with the outfielder evolving from a complementary piece into a primary offensive catalyst for Chicago. Alongside teammates Kyle Tucker and Seiya Suzuki, who have combined for over 50 home runs, Crow-Armstrong is a pivotal part of the Cubs’ offensive engine driving their playoff push.
Balancing Health and Performance for a Deep Postseason Run
As Shota Imanaga nears a return and Pete Crow-Armstrong opts to conserve energy, the Cubs’ approach signals a focus on long-term success. Prioritizing recovery and roster depth while maintaining momentum reflects the organization’s commitment to navigating the rigors of a demanding baseball season. Manager Craig Counsell and the front office are making measured choices to optimize the team’s chances for a deep playoff journey, weighing every decision carefully as the race intensifies.
With strong individual efforts and smart management strategies, the Cubs look poised to continue their dominance in the NL Central and aim for a postseason run fueled by resilience, depth, and calculated risk-taking. Fans can expect an exciting stretch as the Cubs’ narratives of recovery and leadership unfold in the coming weeks.