Deshaun Watson was brought to the Cleveland Browns in the 2022 offseason with hopes that he would lead the team to championship contention. However, his time with the Browns has been hindered by frequent injuries, most recently an Achilles tear that could sideline him for the entire 2025 season, and his performance when healthy has been inconsistent. The unfolding situation has intensified the Deshaun Watson trade rumors Cleveland Browns fans are following closely.
In the Cleveland sports community, notable voices have suggested the Browns should consider moving on from Watson, especially since the team currently carries four quarterbacks: veterans Joe Flacco and Kenny Pickett, and rookies Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders. Former Browns return specialist Josh Cribbs weighed in on The Return Show podcast, recommending the franchise seek second- and third-round draft picks along with cash in exchange for Watson.
“Not the best, but they will get something for him. (Watson’s new team) will pay a portion of his salary, and the Browns will eat the rest.”
—Josh Cribbs, Former Return Specialist
Similarly, ESPN Cleveland’s Tom Rizzo expressed on The Really Big Show that it would benefit everyone if Watson were traded out of the Browns’ locker room in Berea. Rizzo believes Watson’s time in Cleveland is over but acknowledges his career might continue elsewhere due to his talent and previous recognition as a three-time Pro Bowler.
“I think it would be in everyone’s best interest for him to move on, to get him out of the locker room in Berea. I think his career is over in Cleveland, but I don’t think his career is done. Do you think there is a team that would take a chance on a guy who’s gone through a lot, but has a lot of potential and is a former three-time Pro Bowler?”
—Tom Rizzo, ESPN Cleveland Analyst
Despite these perspectives, Browns fans appear skeptical that any team would be willing to assume Watson’s contract or public relations challenges, resulting in dismissive reactions across social media and fan forums.
“Nobody’s gonna touch him for that kind of money”
—Cleveland Browns Fan
“He’ll be cut next off-season”
—Cleveland Browns Fan
“Who wants this PR headache? Seriously”
—Cleveland Browns Fan
Additional fan commentary underscores the widespread pessimism toward Watson’s trade value and future in the NFL, reflecting deep frustration and hopelessness among the Browns’ base.
“This again? He. Has. Zero. Trade. Value.”
—Cleveland Browns Fan
“He should call it quits while he’s at it.”
—Cleveland Browns Fan
“Just stop digging the hole deeper. Cut your losses.”
—Cleveland Browns Fan
Positive Remarks from Shedeur Sanders Amid Browns’ Quarterback Discussion
Not all voices surrounding the Browns are critical, as rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders expressed supportive comments about Watson. Speaking to Kay Adams on Tuesday, Sanders highlighted Watson’s involvement and presence within the team environment.
“He’s active in there. He’s in all the meetings. It’s cool talking to him.”
—Shedeur Sanders, Cleveland Browns Quarterback
The Browns are set to begin organized team activities (OTAs) on May 27, continuing through June 19, with a mandatory minicamp scheduled for June 10 to 12. As the team prepares for the upcoming season, the quarterback situation remains under close observation, especially with the uncertainties surrounding Watson’s health and trade potential.
The ongoing Deshaun Watson trade rumors Cleveland Browns supporters are tracking reflect broader questions about the team’s future direction. With Watson’s injury history and off-field controversies, Cleveland’s leadership faces difficult decisions about whether to retain him or pursue a trade amid fan skepticism. How this situation resolves will likely influence the Browns’ quarterback dynamics and offseason moves moving forward.