The Philadelphia Phillies face a significant decision regarding their roster as the upcoming offseason approaches, particularly concerning J.T. Realmuto’s free agency and Phillies future. With Realmuto and Kyle Schwarber both set to become free agents next winter, the team must evaluate the value of keeping their veteran players moving forward.
While Kyle Schwarber currently appears to be the stronger player, J.T. Realmuto’s contributions cannot be overlooked. Although Realmuto’s offensive numbers have declined, his defensive skills remain elite, making him a valuable asset behind the plate. This balance of experience and defensive ability presents the Phillies with a complex choice about their core lineup.
Realmuto’s Performance and Defensive Strengths Amid Aging
J.T. Realmuto has exhibited signs of aging, with his home run totals decreasing steadily from 22 to 20, then 14 over the last three seasons, and just four so far this year. Despite this, he has maintained relatively stable batting average and on-base percentages. Realmuto’s defensive prowess remains significant, even though he no longer holds the Gold Glove distinction he earned in 2019 and 2023. His selection as a three-time All-Star indicates his established reputation, but it is likely he has played in his final midsummer classic.
Jim Bowden of The Athletic highlighted Realmuto’s ongoing value despite recent declines:
“He remains a strong game caller who can stop the running game with elite pop time and above-average caught stealing numbers, although he doesn’t grade out well in framing. A veteran catcher with his resume will have starting jobs waiting for him in free agency,”
—Jim Bowden, Baseball Analyst
Currently, Realmuto is hitting .240 with five home runs and 19 RBIs this season. His 99 OPS+, while the lowest of his career since his second major league year, still aligns with league-average production. When paired with his top-tier defensive skills, his performance is solid for a 34-year-old catcher.
Phillies’ Upcoming Roster Choices Amid Veteran Departures
With both Realmuto and Schwarber reaching free agency, the Phillies face a pivotal offseason that could mark the end of the existing core group. The management will need to weigh whether to re-sign Realmuto, who may still have starting roles available elsewhere given his defensive expertise, or pivot toward younger talent. This decision will influence the team’s competitive outlook and strategic direction going forward.
Realmuto’s steady defensive contributions and experience make him an important figure in this evaluation, especially as the team considers how to balance veteran presence with future potential on the roster. The coming months will reveal how the Phillies prioritize their investments in free agency and plan their roster for the seasons ahead.