On Saturday, concern grew within the New York Knicks organization as a key insider warned that without altering their starting lineup, the team risks an early elimination from the Eastern Conference Finals by the Indiana Pacers. Entering Game 3 down 0-2 and having lost home-court advantage, the Knicks face mounting pressure to make critical adjustments to avoid falling behind further.
Current Struggles with the Knicks’ Starting Lineup in Playoff Series
The Knicks’ starters have underperformed since the beginning of the year, posting a combined -1.4 plus-minus rating from January 1 onward. Despite overcoming similar issues earlier in the playoffs against the Pistons and Celtics, the team has been outscored by 29 points against Indiana, failing to secure a win so far. This poor performance from the starting five has intensified calls for coach Tom Thibodeau to reconsider his rotation ahead of Game 3 in Indiana.
Among the options for a shake-up, two players stand out as potential additions to the starting lineup: Mitchell Robinson and Miles McBride. Notably, when these two were on the court together during Game 2, they reversed a 10-point deficit generated by the starters and posted a +10 net rating. Their energy and defensive contributions have been crucial in keeping the Knicks competitive.
Josh Hart Supports Increasing Mitchell Robinson’s Playing Time
Although a starting lineup change seems unlikely due to financial and strategic investments in the current starters, the possibility of inserting Robinson or McBride into the starting five remains under discussion. Of the two, Mitchell Robinson appears to have the strongest case for increased minutes at the beginning of games, with teammate Josh Hart emphasizing his value.
Man, he’s huge. He’s someone who does just everything. Offensive rebound, defensive rebound, he can guard on the perimeter, guard in the post. He’s a big X factor for us,
Hart stated.
We have to figure out ways — I think he played 30 minutes — figure out ways if he can play more. We’re great with him on. We all have to be willing to sacrifice for the betterment of the team.
—Josh Hart, New York Knicks player
Mitchell Robinson’s Defensive Strengths and Lineup Dilemmas
Robinson’s offensive game has limitations, but his defensive presence and rebounding impact are formidable assets for the Knicks. As an elite offensive rebounder and a capable man-to-man defender—effective even against smaller opponents—he offers a dynamic element on the floor that the starting unit currently lacks. The main challenge for Thibodeau will be determining who moves to the bench if Robinson is elevated to starter, with candidates likely including Karl-Anthony Towns or Josh Hart.
The decision holds significant strategic weight as the Knicks look to halt the Pacers’ momentum and reclaim control over the series. Adjusting Robinson’s minutes or starting status could energize the team’s defense and improve their chances of staying alive in the Eastern Conference Finals.