After losing the closer’s role early in the season due to performance struggles, two-time National League Reliever of the Year Devin Williams is showing signs of reclaiming his place in the bullpen. The New York Yankees face a potential closer debate in 2025 as Williams aims to return to the ninth-inning position he was expected to assume when acquired this winter.
Meanwhile, Luke Weaver has quietly taken over as the Yankees’ closer, impressively posting a 0.40 ERA across 22.2 innings. His strong performances have sparked questions about whether there is a genuine controversy brewing over the team’s bullpen leadership.
Luke Weaver Emphasizes Confidence in Devin Williams’ Recovery
Despite the speculation, Weaver dismissed any concerns about tension in the Yankees’ bullpen. Speaking in a video shared by SNY Yankees on X, Weaver said,
“He is obviously one of the best in the game — There’s adjustment periods with anything.”
He underscored his belief in Williams’ talent and progress, stressing the absence of any conflict regarding the closer’s role.
Devin Williams’ Turnaround after Early Season Setbacks
Williams struggled significantly in April, posting a 10.03 ERA, which resulted in him losing the closer job following a blown ninth inning against the Toronto Blue Jays. Since then, he has rebounded with six consecutive scoreless appearances, lowering his ERA to 6.50 and contributing critically to the bullpen’s improved performance.
Williams recently demonstrated his regained dominance in a Subway Series matchup against the New York Mets by striking out key batters Pete Alonso, Mark Vientos, and Brandon Nimmo. Yankees manager Aaron Boone expressed optimism about Williams’ trajectory, stating the pitcher is very close to reaching his previous All-Star peak.
Players Address Role Changes with Team-First Mentality
Williams downplayed the significance of his demotion from the closer role when asked if he expects to return to the ninth inning, saying,
“It doesn’t matter right now. It doesn’t matter,”
showing a focus on team success over individual roles.
Reiterating this sentiment, Weaver added,
“I certainly wasn’t worried about him for one second,”
and praised Williams’ current form:
“He’s found his rhythm, he’s controlling his game, his tempo, and he’s just dominant.”
Implications for Yankees’ Bullpen Strategy Moving Forward
The unfolding situation highlights a balancing act for the Yankees in managing two highly capable pitchers competing for the closer role in 2025. With Weaver excelling in the position and Williams surging back to form, the team’s bullpen depth has strengthened significantly.
How the Yankees handle this dynamic could shape their postseason pitching strategy, as maintaining harmony and maximizing both pitchers’ strengths will be crucial for their success in high-pressure situations.