Buffalo Bills running back James Cook has not ruled out the possibility of a holdout this summer as he pursues a new deal before the 2025 NFL season. The James Cook potential $15 million contract extension is a significant topic as both sides explore options amid his goal to join the league’s top earners at his position.
Evaluating a Fair Market Value for Cook’s Extension
Albert Breer of Sports Illustrated recently highlighted that a contract paying roughly $15 million per year could satisfy both Cook and the Bills. This estimate aligns with recent running back extensions, such as those signed by Saquon Barkley and Derrick Henry, suggesting a middle ground currently exists in that salary range.
Cook’s 2023 season stats back this valuation, featuring 1,009 rushing yards with an impressive 4.9 yards per carry, 16 rushing touchdowns, and only one fumble on 207 carries. He also contributed receiving yards with 32 receptions totaling 258 yards and two touchdowns, averaging 8.1 yards per reception.
Comparing Cook’s Salary to His Peers at Running Back
At approximately $15 million annually, Cook would rank as the fourth-highest paid running back in the NFL, positioning him ahead of Jonathan Taylor, who earns $14 million, and Alvin Kamara, who has a $12.25 million average salary. However, this figure falls short of the contracts held by Barkley ($20 million AAV), Henry, and Christian McCaffrey ($19 million AAV).
Considering Cook was the 63rd overall pick and plays a position that NFL teams often undervalue in second contracts, the proposed figure reflects his recent success, including consecutive Pro Bowl appearances and tying for the league lead in rushing touchdowns during the 2024 campaign.
Contractual and Team Perspectives on Cook’s Future
Currently, James Cook’s contract includes a $5.271 million base salary and a $355,374 signing bonus in 2025, with a cap hit of $5.701 million, leaving him scheduled to become a free agent in 2026. Despite these numbers, Bills general manager Brandon Beane expressed skepticism in March over an imminent extension, indicating such a deal is not expected “anytime soon.”
The Bills have a track record under Beane’s leadership of regarding running backs as expendable resources. Past starters like Devin Singletary and LeSean McCoy were replaced by more cost-effective alternatives, reflecting this team philosophy.
Buffalo’s Roster Plans May Signal Transition at Running Back
As Cook approaches a contract year, Buffalo appears ready to consider other options. Ray Davis, selected 128th overall in the 2024 NFL Draft, could see expanded playing time this season. Additionally, the Bills might utilize a mid-round 2026 draft pick to add another running back. Although $15 million per season could be a fair market value for Cook, it seems unlikely Buffalo will meet that figure in their negotiations.
The Outlook for Cook and the Bills Moving Forward
James Cook’s pursuit of a $15 million contract marks a critical phase in his career as he aims to leverage his recent performance into greater compensation. Meanwhile, the Bills face decisions on managing salary cap space and roster composition, balancing loyalty to Cook with their established strategy of cost optimization at running back.