The Boston Red Sox’s current struggles this season have been closely linked to Trevor Story’s unexpected lack of form, significantly influencing the team’s overall performance. After securing Story with a $140 million contract over six years, expectations were high that he would replicate the strong offensive numbers he achieved with the Colorado Rockies, where his OPS+ consistently exceeded 120. Instead, through the first 51 games of 2025, Story has posted a disappointing 65 OPS+ and managed only nine extra-base hits, well below what was anticipated from a player of his caliber and contract size.
Alex Cora’s Approach to Managing Story’s Slump
Boston’s manager, Alex Cora, acknowledged the difficulties Story has faced but emphasized that the player’s effort remains steadfast. Cora shared that the strategy has been to temporarily “disconnect” Story to allow him to reset mentally and observe the game from a different angle, rather than trying to force immediate improvement.
“Disconnect him today. Maybe tomorrow. And keep working,”
Cora said on Sunday, as reported by The Post.
“It’s not a lack of working. It’s been a lot. And maybe just kind like back up and just watch the game from a different perspective.”
—Alex Cora, Boston Red Sox Manager
This approach was reflected during the recent game against the Baltimore Orioles, where Story was given the day off as part of this process. Despite not playing that day, the day of rest appeared necessary given his ongoing struggles at the plate and in the field.
Trade Speculations and Contract Concerns Surrounding Story
As frustration mounts, speculation grows regarding the Red Sox’s potential moves before the trade deadline, with some suggesting that the team might explore trading Story. However, with Story’s current performance failing to justify his contract, there appears to be limited interest from other clubs willing to absorb his large salary. This complicates the Red Sox’s options and adds uncertainty to how they might navigate the situation long-term. Even so, the organization likely feels pressure to address the issue if Story’s slump persists, given the high expectations tied to his acquisition.
Implications for the Red Sox Season and Future Decisions
Trevor Story’s ongoing struggles have placed the Red Sox in a challenging position as they aim to regain competitive form in 2025. Alex Cora’s strategy of patience and giving Story space to regain confidence reflects the urgency and complexity of the situation. The team’s ability to find a resolution—whether through internal adjustments or potential trade talks—will be critical to salvaging the season and future roster planning. With other American League East teams advancing, how the Red Sox manage this adversity could significantly influence their standing moving forward.