As June approaches, fans eagerly prepare for one of baseball’s most celebrated traditions: All-Star voting. This year, the Minnesota Twins are showcasing a blend of promising new talent and seasoned veterans vying to represent the American League this July, with Byron Buxton leading the charge. Fans and insiders alike will focus on standout performances as they select the nine offensive players for each league’s squad.
Among the Twins roster, several players have emerged as worthy contenders for the 2025 MLB All-Star Game. This article highlights the top five candidates, ranked from those less likely to make the team to near-certainties.
Harrison Bader Brings Defensive Stability Despite Offensive Challenges
Harrison Bader may not immediately catch the eye on an All-Star ballot crowded with power hitters and flashy stats, but his impact on the Twins cannot be overstated. Sharing the highest rWAR on the team alongside Byron Buxton, Bader has been a defensive cornerstone. His versatility in the outfield—covering both left and center field—and steady performance have made him one of Minnesota’s most reliable defenders.
Nevertheless, All-Star selections usually favor offensive output, and Bader’s numbers there, while respectable, may hold him back. With a career-best OPS+ of 122 and 11 extra-base hits through 46 games, his bat is solid but not spectacular. Given the depth of American League outfielders with stronger offensive stats, Bader’s chances to secure a spot may depend on late-season injuries or roster adjustments.
Jhoan Duran’s Dominance in Relief Positions Him Well
Relief pitchers often occupy unpredictable territory in All-Star selections, but Jhoan Duran has made a compelling case with his electrifying pitching. Armed with a fastball that could grab headlines in any highlight reel, Duran boasts a sub-1.50 ERA and 30 strikeouts in just over 25 innings pitched this season.
Unlike offensive players, pitchers’ All-Star spots are determined by managers and players, which favors Duran given his dominance. Despite stronger name recognition for some closers, few match his combination of power and effectiveness. If his performance holds through June, he will likely earn his first All-Star nod.
Pablo López’s Consistent Excellence Keeps Him in the Conversation
Pablo López’s value lies in his steady success and impressive track record. A former All-Star, he has enjoyed one of his best seasons in 2025, with a career-best 2.31 ERA and an outstanding 177 ERA+. His control remains sharp with a 4.4% walk rate, complemented by advanced metrics placing him in the top 10% in Pitching Run Value and limiting hard contact.
López may not generate the same buzz as flashier pitchers, but his dependability anchors the Twins’ starting rotation. The American League All-Star roster requires depth, and López’s experience and consistency make him a logical choice for inclusion in the midsummer classic.
Joe Ryan’s Breakout Season Establishes Him as a Front-Runner
This season, Joe Ryan has distinguished himself as one of the American League’s most formidable pitchers. Following a challenging 2024, Ryan entered 2025 determined to excel, and his fastball has become a major weapon. His strikeout and walk statistics shine, while his surface numbers—such as a 2.57 ERA, 53 innings in 11 starts, and five wins—are impressive to coaches and players alike.
Since pitchers aren’t subject to fan voting, Ryan’s stellar form makes him a clear frontrunner for a roster spot. If the All-Star Game occurred today, Ryan could even be considered for a starting pitcher role, showcasing just how far he has elevated his game this season.
Byron Buxton’s Health and Performance Fuel Optimism for 2025 All-Star Spot
Byron Buxton stands atop the Twins’ All-Star candidates with a reputation well earned by those who follow the team closely. When healthy, he is one of baseball’s most electrifying center fielders. After years hampered by injuries, 2025 marks his resurgence. Buxton has returned to full-time center field duty, and he currently leads all American League center fielders in WAR, outpacing high-profile players like Cody Bellinger and Julio Rodriguez.
Nevertheless, the perennial concern is Buxton’s ability to stay healthy through the season. If he remains on the field, his combination of fans’ enthusiasm, coaches’ respect, and peer acknowledgment should make him an undeniable All-Star selection. His dynamic play has been the lifeblood of the Twins this year, and a possible All-Star game appearance in his home state of Georgia adds an exciting storyline.
Twins’ Emerging All-Star Talent Signals Positive Outlook for 2025
While the Twins may not command the headline-grabbing offensive stars of some coastal teams, their roster is quietly assembling a competitive group of All-Star talent. The mixture of dependable starting pitching, powerful relief arms, and athletic outfielders gives Minnesota a well-rounded presence for the midsummer classic.
As All-Star voting opens in early June, Twins supporters may have multiple players to watch and cheer for. Whether it is a surprise breakout or a return to form for established players like Buxton, the 2025 season promises compelling narratives and exciting performances that could reshape Minnesota’s standing in the league’s elite.