In Game 4 of the Western Conference Finals on Minnesota’s home court, Anthony Edwards faced significant challenges as the Timberwolves fell 128-126 to the Oklahoma City Thunder. After delivering a commanding 30-point effort in the previous game, Edwards struggled mightily, finishing with only 16 points on 13 shot attempts. His performance stood in stark contrast to expectations for the young star, especially as the Timberwolves fought to avoid being pushed into a 3-1 series deficit.

Bench Stepping Up Amid Star Struggles

While Edwards and teammate Julius Randle struggled—Randle notably hitting just one shot the entire night—the Timberwolves bench provided a spark. Nickeil Alexander-Walker and Donte DiVincenzo led the effort from the second unit, delivering their best performances of the series to help Minnesota stay within striking distance until the closing moments. Their contributions prevented a more lopsided defeat and demonstrated the importance of role players in critical playoff situations.

Stephen A. Smith Critiques Edwards’ Performance Under Pressure

With the series still hanging in the balance, sports commentator Stephen A. Smith expressed strong disappointment in Edwards’ showing, calling it unacceptable for a player of his caliber during such a crucial game. Edwards ranked third on the team in shot attempts despite the Timberwolves potentially facing elimination. Smith argued that true superstars have the responsibility to elevate their play in the most difficult moments.

At some point in time, it’s about you … When you go to a negotiating table, and you ‘Yo, I’m worth $50 mil,’ it ain’t to play the right way,

Smith said adamantly.

It’s when things are going wrong, I’m the dude who’s gonna make it right. That’s why LeBron is who he is. That’s why Steph is who he is. That’s why Kobe is who he was. That’s why MJ is who he was.

—Stephen A. Smith, Sports Commentator

Debate Over Playing Style Versus Aggressiveness in High-Stakes Games

Brian Windhorst, NBA analyst, offered a more measured perspective by acknowledging the difficulty Edwards faces against Oklahoma City’s stingy defense. Windhorst emphasized the importance of adhering to the team’s game plan rather than forcing plays. However, Smith firmly rejected this rationale, insisting that the game’s biggest stars find ways to create impact despite defensive pressure or strategic constraints.

Missed Opportunities as Oklahoma City Maintains Edge

Throughout the game, Oklahoma City maintained a comfortable lead, capitalizing on Edwards’ inability to consistently showcase his offensive skills. With the final score separated by just two points, Smith argued that Edwards should have done more to influence the outcome, especially when the Timberwolves’ aspirations for reaching their first NBA Finals were at stake.

We’re not saying that Ant-Man had an awful game,

Smith claimed.

What we’re saying is, 13 shot attempts? 16 points? On your home turf with you on the verge of falling to an insurmountable 3-1 deficit, with the dude that got league MVP in front of your face dropping 40…

—Stephen A. Smith, Sports Commentator

Comparison Drawn Between Edwards and James Harden’s Playoff Quietness

Smith drew a direct parallel between Edwards’ recent shortcomings and the postseason performances of James Harden, who has previously been criticized for similar quiet moments during pivotal playoff games. Harden, known as one of the league’s most prolific scorers, has faced scrutiny when reducing his shot volume in critical matchups, particularly in the Clippers’ first-round exit against the Denver Nuggets.

What do we complain about with James Harden? The money maker, one of the most prolific scorers the game has ever seen. You wait until Game 6 or 7s to attempt nine and 10 shots,

Smith said, calling out the Clippers All-Star.

We ain’t get on him for the amount of points he scored. We got him because, where’s the attempts?

—Stephen A. Smith, Sports Commentator

Harden’s reluctance to aggressively pursue scoring opportunities arguably contributed to the Clippers’ defeat and their missing a chance to advance further in the playoffs. This comparison highlights the challenge faced by Edwards in proving his resilience and ability to overcome defensive schemes when the stakes are highest.

Edwards’ Upcoming Chance to Change the Narrative

With Minnesota facing a possible elimination, Edwards has one final opportunity in Game 6 back in Oklahoma City to prove critics like Stephen A. Smith wrong. Whether he can deliver a strong, assertive performance may determine not only the Timberwolves’ fate but also how his growth as a postseason leader is perceived. Regardless of the outcome, showing a determined effort will be key to earning respect and silencing doubts about his ability to perform under pressure.