On Memorial Day, MLB.com unveiled its predictions for the 2025 All-MLB Team, which honors the league’s top performers at each position based on an analysis of the season‘s first two months and forecasts through the rest of the year. This selection, compiled by MLB.com insiders and analysts, aimed to highlight players expected to earn spots on the First and Second All-MLB Teams by season’s end, sparking intense reaction from fans about who was included and who was left out. The focus of much of the discussion was the Luke Weaver snub controversy in All-MLB team predictions, which ignited passionate responses from supporters and critics alike.

Reliever Mason Miller’s Selection Over Luke Weaver Provokes Outcry

A major point of contention centered on the decision to include Oakland Athletics’ reliever Mason Miller on the Second Team despite his shaky start to the 2025 season. Miller, who impressed as a rookie with 28 saves, a 2.49 ERA, and a 0.88 WHIP, has struggled this year, posting a 5.79 ERA early on. Manny Randhawa of MLB.com defended the choice by noting Miller’s potential to bounce back due to his powerful pitching arsenal.

(W)hile he’s gotten off to a rough start in 2025 (5.79 ERA), our voters feel that Miller – an All-Star in his rookie season last year – is too good to not turn things around with his blazing fastball and devastating slider,

—Manny Randhawa, MLB.com

However, Yankees fans were far less forgiving of this rationale, especially given the exclusion of Luke Weaver. Weaver, who transitioned from middle relief to closer during a key stretch last September when Clay Holmes faltered, was dominant in New York’s push to the World Series. This season, despite the Yankees acquiring Devin Williams for closing duties, it was Weaver who reclaimed the closer role amid Williams’ early struggles, delivering eight saves in nine chances with an impressive 0.73 ERA and 0.69 WHIP.

Fans voiced their frustration loudly.

Luke Weaver snubbed,

one fan remarked.

Mason Miller has a 5 ERA and he’s here over Luke Weaver lmao,

another commenter added.

Juan Soto’s Spot on the Team Adds Fuel to Fan Discontent

Another lightning rod for criticism was Juan Soto’s placement on the All-MLB Second Team despite his subpar statistics so far this season. The former Yankee turned Mets outfielder has struggled with a .228 batting average, eight home runs, and 25 RBIs in 54 games, numbers that many viewed as unworthy of such an honor. Nonetheless, MLB.com’s Randhawa justified Soto’s selection by invoking his status as one of baseball’s elite hitters despite the rough start.

Soto, in his first season with the Mets, hasn’t gotten off to the start he’d like, but he’s still one of the game’s most elite hitters,

—Manny Randhawa, MLB.com

This defense failed to convince many fans, even die-hard Mets supporters, who openly questioned Soto’s merit for inclusion.

What is Juan Soto doing there???

There’s been like 15 outfielders more worthy than juan soto,

I’m a Mets fan. Soto shouldn’t be on here,

Impact and Ongoing Debate Over Selection Criteria and Fan Trust

The release of the All-MLB Team predictions demonstrates how major league baseball’s fan bases are highly engaged and quick to challenge expert opinions, particularly when beloved players are overlooked or players with weaker current performances are favored. The Luke Weaver snub controversy in All-MLB team predictions underscores the deep emotional investment fans have in roster decisions and the intense scrutiny faced by analysts when projecting season outcomes. How MLB.com’s voters balance current statistics with projected performance remains a contentious issue, one that will likely fuel similar debates as the season progresses.

For the Yankees and their followers, Weaver’s remarkable effectiveness as a closer this year makes his omission all the more difficult to accept, highlighting how subjective and complicated All-MLB team selections can be in midseason assessments. Meanwhile, players like Soto continue to benefit from reputations built over prior seasons, even when current numbers disappoint.

As the 2025 campaign unfolds, further evaluations from MLB.com and other analysts will be watched closely, with fans eager to see whether controversial choices will be vindicated or revised. Until then, the debate around the All-MLB Team choices remains a lively and disputed topic among the baseball community.