The Carolina Panthers approached the 2025 NFL Draft aiming to address multiple defensive needs, particularly for a strong pass rusher. Although many anticipated the team using the eighth overall pick on an edge rusher like Jalon Walker or Mykel Williams, the Panthers surprised observers by selecting wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan. This decision aimed to bolster the offense and form a powerful Bryce Young and Tetairoa McMillan Panthers pairing that fans can anticipate in the coming seasons.

McMillan, initially underrated by many evaluators before the draft, showed qualities that made this choice compelling. While he may lack elite speed and polished route-running techniques, McMillan’s size, intelligence, and natural ability to control games distinguish him as a dominant receiver talent. His skill set is expected to provide excellent support for quarterback Bryce Young as the latter continues to develop his game.

Supplementing Pass Rush with Strategic Mid-Round Picks

After trading back in the second round, the Panthers addressed their pass-rushing deficiencies by selecting Nic Scourton and Princely Umanmielen. Scourton, a 265-pound athletic player from Purdue and Texas A&M, possesses significant upside that matches the Panthers’ defensive scheme well. Umanmielen, who showed flashes of effectiveness at Florida and Mississippi, has game-breaking potential despite concerns regarding his consistency and motivation.

The Panthers’ coaching staff faces the challenge of maximizing Umanmielen’s effort throughout games, which could transform him into a crucial defensive asset. Alongside Scourton, these picks help solidify the team’s edge defense, a vital area of need.

Trevor Etienne Emerges as Key Backfield Addition Amid Injury Setback

Trevor Etienne’s selection in the fourth round proved to be excellent value, especially considering news that Jonathon Brooks, the second-round pick from last year, will miss the entire 2025 season. Etienne is a quick and inventive running back who adds versatility by contributing as a receiver out of the backfield and lining up in the slot during passing situations.

Though Etienne is smaller and fits mostly as a situational or rotational player, his potential for growth is promising. However, consistency remains crucial for him to secure a significant role on the Panthers’ offense.

Additional Mid-Round Picks Add Depth to Defense and Offense

The team also selected Lathan Ransom in the fourth round, a defensive back capable of playing both free and strong safety positions. Ransom impressed in 2022 but struggled with injuries the following year. He is expected to provide valuable nickel safety coverage as a rookie, with the potential to develop into a starting role through experience and performance.

In the fifth round, Carolina picked nose tackle Cam Jackson, known for his size and moments of impactful play, although he will need to increase the physical intensity of his game. Mitchell Evans, chosen in the same round, offers versatility as a well-rounded tight end who could serve as the team’s third option at the position.

Late-Round Selection and Free Agency Add Speed and Pressure

In the sixth round, Jimmy Horn Jr. was added to bring speed, quickness, and return capabilities to the Panthers’ offense. Horn’s athleticism is expected to enhance the team‘s special teams and provide a dynamic threat in open space.

Additionally, free-agent signing Jared Harrison-Hunte, a defensive lineman known for his explosive first step, is anticipated to generate pressure upfront by effectively penetrating opposing backfields. His ability to disrupt plays aligns with Carolina’s goal of reinforcing its pass rush.

Draft Grade Reflects Solid Team Building with Immediate and Future Impact

The Panthers earned an A- grade for their draft moves, successfully addressing several critical needs and adding valuable depth. Although the team passed on cornerbacks despite expectations, their focus on impactful receivers, pass rushers, and versatile players was clear.

The top three picks—McMillan, Scourton, and Umanmielen—are projected to contribute early in the season, while Etienne and Ransom’s roles as rookies are expected to expand as the year progresses. This strategy highlights Carolina’s blend of immediate upgrades and promising talent for the future.