The Toronto Maple Leafs are facing significant changes ahead of the next season after failing to advance deep into the postseason. Speculation is mounting that Mitch Marner not returning to Maple Leafs is becoming increasingly likely, with a well-regarded analyst stating on June 13 that Marner will almost certainly test free agency. This development could force the organization to rethink its roster strategy as it seeks a path back to playoff contention.

Marner, 28, had an impressive 2024-25 campaign, finishing with 27 goals and 75 assists, totaling 102 points across 81 games. His consistent offensive output makes him a coveted player on the open market, and several teams are expected to pursue him aggressively if he doesn’t remain with Toronto.

Potential Impact on John Tavares’ Future with the Team

Industry insider Andy Strickland highlighted that Marner’s probable departure might pave the way for John Tavares to return to the Maple Leafs. Earlier this season, the team seemed prepared to let the veteran center move on, but with Marner’s exit looming, their perspective could shift toward re-signing Tavares to maintain stability within the squad.

“Marner leaving Toronto could open the door for John Tavares to return. Heading into the season the Leafs were expected to allow the veteran center to walk. With Marner leaving that mindset has changed. #LeafsForever”— Andy Strickland, Pundit

Though Marner is generally acknowledged as a more complete player, keeping Tavares on the roster helps stabilize team depth and frees up salary flexibility to allocate resources elsewhere. While the narrative remains speculative and no official confirmation has been issued, this possible move could influence the Maple Leafs’ composition and competitiveness in the near future.

Options the Maple Leafs May Consider to Fill Marner’s Role

Replacing Marner’s offensive prowess will be a challenge, but the Maple Leafs will have various avenues to explore this summer. Among the top free agents available, Brock Boeser and Nikolaj Ehlers stand out as premier scorers who could command a significant contract but would bring notable offensive skills. Pursuing these players would signal an aggressive effort by Toronto to remain a top contender.

Alternatively, the team might target experienced veterans such as Brad Marchand, provided the financial terms align with Toronto’s salary cap considerations. Additionally, the trade market offers possible options, with names like Jason Robertson and JJ Peterka representing significant talent that could be acquired if the Maple Leafs opt to pursue a star-level player through a deal.

Marner reportedly seeks an annual salary exceeding $14 million, a figure the Maple Leafs may find difficult to accommodate without jeopardizing other roster needs. Thus, allowing Marner to move on would free up substantial cap space to reinforce forward depth and strengthen the defensive lineup.

Planning for a Post-Marner Maple Leafs Roster

Given the mounting indications, preparing for a season without Marner seems the prudent course for Toronto’s management. While the possibility remains that Marner re-signs with the team and all rumors are unfounded, the Maple Leafs cannot afford to delay in evaluating alternatives for one of their key offensive assets. Time is pressing for any negotiations or strategic decisions before the off-season unfolds further.

As the NHL postseason progresses, keeping up with developments through trusted sources such as The Hockey Writers will provide ongoing insight into roster moves and the evolving landscape around the Maple Leafs and beyond.