Geno Smith has quietly established himself as one of the most underrated quarterbacks in the NFL. Over the past three seasons with the Seattle Seahawks, he posted a 27-22 record while throwing 71 touchdown passes. Now with the Las Vegas Raiders, Smith is poised to enhance his impact in the 2025 season, especially with new offensive leadership and weapons around him. This comparison between Geno Smith and Sam Darnold highlights why Smith’s role could significantly outpace his counterpart’s in the coming year.
New Opportunities with the Raiders’ Improved Offensive Setup
Smith’s transition to the Raiders brings fresh prospects, particularly with Chip Kelly joining as the offensive playcaller. Kelly’s innovative approach combined with Smith’s experience could create a dynamic on the field. Additionally, having a standout tight end like Brock Bowers to target strengthens Smith’s passing options. The Raiders have endured several difficult seasons, often due to inconsistent quarterback performance. Smith’s arrival is expected to stabilize and elevate the team’s offense.
Expert Opinions Highlight Smith’s Advantage Over Other Veteran QBs
Jeffri Chadiha recently discussed veteran quarterbacks changing teams this offseason and named Geno Smith as the clear choice to make the most significant impact. Chadiha noted,
“There’s a long list here — including Sam Darnold (Seattle), Justin Fields (New York Jets), Russell Wilson (New York Giants) and Daniel Jones (Indianapolis) — but Geno Smith is the obvious choice.”
He emphasized Smith’s familiarity with his current coaching staff and his steady performance since becoming a starter.
According to Chadiha,
“The Raiders traded a third-round pick to acquire him from Seattle, and he’s walking into a situation that is extremely familiar to him. Head coach Pete Carroll was leading the Seahawks back in 2022 when that team decided to deal Russell Wilson to Denver and elevate Smith from backup to starter after Smith spent several years operating as a journeyman backup. Smith has been a solid signal-caller in the three seasons since that point, as he’s averaged 4,075 passing yards and thrown 71 touchdown passes and 35 interceptions.”
What This Means for the 2025 Season and Beyond
The combination of Geno Smith’s growth, the Raiders’ commitment to upgrading the offense, and Chip Kelly’s coaching creates optimism around Smith potentially outperforming other quarterbacks like Sam Darnold. Smith’s proven ability to lead under pressure and familiarity with coach Pete Carroll’s system give him an advantage heading into 2025. This situation could reshape the narrative around the Raiders’ quarterback position and signal a turning point for the team’s competitiveness.
As the season unfolds, Smith’s performance will be a critical factor in determining the Raiders’ success and how the Geno Smith vs Sam Darnold 2025 impact comparison ultimately plays out.