During the Saturday game between the Boston Red Sox and the New York Yankees at Fenway Park, a striking scene unfolded that left many baseball fans puzzled. Bridget, a Red Sox supporter who traveled all the way from Vermont, wore a Red Sox cap while also donning a judge’s robe, loudly cheering for Aaron Judge, the Yankees slugger and arguably the most hated opponent in the stadium. This unusual contradiction triggered widespread discussion around what it means to support a team or player.

The Uncommon Mix of Loyalties and Fan Identity

Bridget’s enthusiasm for Judge stands in stark contrast to the typical Red Sox fan’s fervor for their team and disdain for the Yankees’ stars. Tom Carroll of WEEI shared video footage capturing her outspoken support, which jarred many who have grown up fiercely loyal to Red Sox legends in opposition to Yankees icons like Derek Jeter, Don Mattingly, Thurman Munson, or Mickey Mantle. The idea of rooting simultaneously for a beloved local team and the enemy’s top hitter strains conventional baseball loyalties and fan culture expectations.

Reflection on What Defines a Fan’s Allegiance

For many, allegiance in baseball goes beyond the players to the heart of rivalry and tradition. Imagining oneself a Red Sox fan while admiring a Yankees star seems nearly impossible given decades of competition and emotional investment. Bridget’s example challenges this norm and forces a reflection on how personal fandom can sometimes defy typical boundaries, opening a complex dialogue among loyalists about where true admiration lies in the sport.

“I don’t think I’ve ever seen anything like that, and I hope I never do again.” —Tom Carroll, WEEI
“Bridget can, though, and for that we tip our caps… I guess.” —Tom Carroll, WEEI