J.J. McCarthy, the Minnesota Vikings’ 10th overall pick in 2024, missed his entire rookie season due to a meniscus tear. Despite the setback, McCarthy is poised to make a strong impact in the 2025 season, offering fantasy football managers a promising quarterback profile as he returns fully healed and ready to start.

Strong Support System Enhances McCarthy’s Prospects

The Vikings’ coaching staff has built an offense designed to maximize McCarthy’s abilities. With key skill players led by star wide receiver Justin Jefferson and a reliable offensive line, McCarthy will have the support necessary to succeed in his first full season as a starting NFL quarterback. This environment is expected to boost his effectiveness and fantasy value alike.

Collegiate Performance Shows High Efficiency and Growth

During his three years at Michigan, McCarthy moved from backup to starter after surpassing Cade McNamara in 2022. Though Michigan’s run-focused offense limited his passing volume, McCarthy excelled on a per-play basis, consistently ranking in the 90th percentile or better. He exhibited notable improvement in his second year as a starter, maintaining higher accuracy even as his passing attempts decreased.