Patrick Mahomes has been seen as the NFL’s top quarterback for over five years, leading the Kansas City Chiefs to three Super Bowl victories. However, as the 2025 season approaches, an NFL analyst claims that Josh Allen, the 2024 MVP, has now surpassed Mahomes as the league’s best quarterback.
For years, Mahomes has stood out as a clutch performer, eclipsing legends like Tom Brady and maintaining his dominance in critical moments. While other quarterbacks such as Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen have earned MVP honors, Mahomes’ consistent success in postseason play solidified his reputation.
Yet, Sam Monson, a respected NFL analyst, recently stated his belief that Mahomes no longer holds the title of best quarterback. Monson highlighted Allen’s recent MVP season and suggested that Allen has taken over as the top signal-caller in the league following Mahomes’ decisive loss to the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl 59.
I think Allen’s the guy now,
—Sam Monson, NFL analyst
This viewpoint has sparked debate among fans and experts alike. While Mahomes’ achievements remain significant, Allen’s rise signals a shift in the quarterback landscape heading into the new season.
Josh Allen’s Rise Highlights Changing NFL Quarterback Hierarchy
Josh Allen’s emergence as the 2024 NFL MVP came amid impressive personal and team performances, marking a high point in his career. Allen demonstrated his ability to manage games efficiently, produce strong statistics, and impact winning outcomes for the Buffalo Bills.
Comparatively, Mahomes endured a tough defeat in Super Bowl 59, which may have influenced public perception about his hold on the best quarterback spot. Such moments often prompt analysts to reconsider rankings, particularly when another player like Allen is performing at an elite level.
Legacy of Patrick Mahomes and Tom Brady’s Records
Patrick Mahomes took over the mantle of the league’s best quarterback from Tom Brady, who had an unmatched career leading to multiple championships. Brady held a winning record against all NFL teams except one, further highlighting the competitive benchmarks Mahomes aimed to surpass.
Mahomes, a former Texas Tech Red Raiders standout, has redefined quarterback success for a new generation, blending athleticism with strategic prowess on the field.
Looking Ahead to the 2025 NFL Season
As the NFL season nears, the debate over who commands the title of best quarterback is expected to intensify. Both Mahomes and Allen will have opportunities to bolster their legacies through performance, leaving fans and analysts eager to see how the quarterback rivalry unfolds.
With talent levels so high and competition fierce, the NFL’s quarterback rankings may continue to evolve, reflecting shifts in team success and individual achievements in the coming years.