Last week, the Hart Trophy was awarded to Winnipeg Jets goaltender Conner Hellebuyck, marking the first time since Carey Price in 2015 that a goalie has received this honor. Despite Nikita Kucherov’s back-to-back seasons with MVP-caliber performances, where he led a declining Tampa Bay Lightning squad into the playoffs, he was again passed over for the Hart Trophy, though he did earn the Ted Lindsay Award from his peers.

Analyzing Kucherov’s Future Odds for the Hart Trophy

Questions arise about whether Kucherov will secure another Hart Trophy as his NHL career continues. Frank Seravalli discussed Kucherov’s chances in a recent segment on Daily Faceoff Live, examining the contrasting views held by media members and players regarding his value on the ice. Seravalli emphasized Kucherov’s unique talent despite the team’s apparent downward trajectory.

Media versus Player Perspectives on MVP and Outstanding Player Awards

Seravalli highlighted a notable rift between how players and the media perceive Nikita Kucherov’s contributions. The Ted Lindsay Award, voted on exclusively by NHL players, named Kucherov the most outstanding player, reflecting their respect for his impact. In contrast, the media selected Hellebuyck as the most valuable player. Additionally, players favored Andrei Vasilevskiy over Hellebuyck as the league’s best goaltender, further illustrating differing opinions.

Debate Over Award Voting Panels and Their Implications

The divergence in voting outcomes raises questions about the potential effects if alternative groups, such as NHL management or specially appointed panels, were responsible for determining these awards. Frank Seravalli, President of the Professional Hockey Writers Association, noted that while the current system generally produces accurate results, the varying viewpoints from distinct voting bodies present an interesting dynamic worth considering.

What the Future Holds for Kucherov and NHL Awards

As Kucherov ages and Tampa Bay faces challenges ahead, the ongoing debate over his Hart Trophy chances highlights the complexity of evaluating player impact from different perspectives. Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see if he can once again earn the Hart despite the clear split between player respect and media recognition. This discussion also illuminates broader questions about how awards should be decided in professional hockey moving forward.

“

[Kucherov is] such a special player. Yes, he’s starting to get a little bit older. Yes, the team in Tampa seems to be deteriorating, at least a little bit. I think they’re on the down-slope as opposed to the up-slope.

But I think it’s really interesting, and this debate sort of ignited on social media again over the weekend, which is the way the media views players and the way that players view players. It’s not lost on anyone that the Ted Lindsey gets awarded to Nikita Kucherov, as voted by his peers. They think he’s the most outstanding player in the world this season. Also interesting was that their player poll came out at some point this year, and Connor Hellebuyck was not picked by the players as the best goalie in the league. That would be Andrei Vasilevskiy.

So you see this disparity, and although two entirely different awards, most-valuable player and most-outstanding player, but nonetheless, a discrepancy, and it does raise the question. What if a different entity were voting on the awards, whether it be management or a selected panel by the NHL or whoever? Obviously not advocating for that as President of the Professional Hockey Writers Association, I think we get it right consistently, but it is interesting to see that different voting panels view it differently.

”
—Frank Seravalli, President of the Professional Hockey Writers Association