Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson enters the 2025 NFL season under intense scrutiny as he stands at a pivotal moment in his career. His development, impacted by injuries and inconsistency, has put the spotlight on his performance as the team’s future heavily depends on his progress this year.

Early Struggles and Limited Playing Time Define Richardson’s Start

Now heading into his third NFL season, Richardson has faced significant challenges while playing less than 800 snaps, resulting in a low 58.7 passing grade from Pro Football Focus. Injuries and struggles with accuracy have hindered his ability to fully showcase his talents on the field. These difficulties have stalled the momentum expected from a former fourth overall pick in the 2023 NFL Draft.

Increased Competition and Injury Concerns During Offseason

The Colts’ offseason added pressure on Richardson with the acquisition of Daniel Jones, brought in to compete for the starting quarterback role. Richardson is also managing a shoulder injury that requires ongoing evaluation, raising concerns about his availability for training camp and the regular season. How quickly he can recover and improve will be a defining factor in his tenure with the team.

“Heading into just his third NFL season, Richardson is already at a crossroads in Indianapolis. Injuries and accuracy issues have plagued his first two seasons, as he’s played less than 800 snaps and has earned just a 58.7 PFF passing grade in that time. This offseason has been just as tumultuous for him, as Daniel Jones was brought in to compete for the starting quarterback job. Richardson is also having his shoulder evaluated for a potential injury. Unless he can make a rapid ascent within the next few months, his time in Indianapolis could be coming to a close far sooner than he expected.” —Dalton Wasserman, PFF Analyst

Pressure Mounts for Colts Leadership and Its Young Quarterback

This season carries significant weight not only for Richardson but also for general manager Chris Ballard and head coach Shane Steichen. The front office has placed high expectations on Richardson to capitalize on his rare athleticism and strong arm, despite early-career setbacks. The franchise’s direction may hinge on Richardson’s ability to evolve into a reliable leader and consistent performer under these circumstances.

Potential Implications for Colts’ Future and Team Ownership

If the Colts fail to secure a playoff berth in the upcoming AFC season, it could accelerate changes in the organization beyond just the player roster. The end of Chris Ballard’s tenure as general manager might coincide with the transition of ownership, as late owner Jim Irsay’s daughters take on larger roles. A new management team may be less inclined to invest in Richardson without marked improvement.

Richardson’s Competitive Challenge Against Daniel Jones

The internal QB competition highlights Richardson’s urgency to prove his value, especially given Daniel Jones’s advantage of a healthy offseason to prepare. Failing to win the starting position against Jones, a former New York Giants quarterback viewed as a castoff hoping to revive his career, would raise serious questions about Richardson’s future with the Colts. Nonetheless, Richardson’s athleticism and potential remain key factors offering hope for a breakthrough season.

The Stakes of the 2025 Season for Anthony Richardson and the Colts

At just 23 years old, Richardson has demonstrated glimpses of skill, especially during his rookie year’s initial starts and important late-season drives. However, recurring injuries and inconsistent accuracy continue to jeopardize his development. How he progresses this season in leadership and on-field performance will significantly impact both his career trajectory and the Colts’ offensive outlook moving forward.