Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott remains a polarizing figure in the NFL as he prepares for the 2025 season. Despite ongoing criticisms about his inconsistent playoff performances and recent injury setbacks, many still regard Dak Prescott predicted top-10 NFL quarterback as a realistic assessment of his current standing in the league.
Prescott’s reputation has seen ups and downs, especially given his 2-5 record in playoff games. Critics emphasize his struggles in the postseason, but there is widespread agreement that when at his peak, he belongs among the top tier of quarterbacks. This perspective is strengthened by his strong showing in 2023 when he finished second in MVP voting before injuries and a difficult following season derailed his momentum. Turning 32 as the 2025 campaign begins, some anticipate his performance may decline further, yet he retains significant support.
CBS Sports analyst Pete Prisco included Prescott in his annual top 100 NFL players list, ranking him at number 90 overall, down from 49 the previous year. Prisco acknowledges Prescott’s limitations last season, noting,
“A year after leading the league with 36 touchdown passes, Prescott was limited to eight games because of injury,”
and added,
“Even before the injury, he wasn’t as sharp as the year before with just 11 touchdown passes and eight picks. But I think he’s closer to the 2023 Prescott again.”
While Prescott’s position among the top 100 players is not unexpected, what stands out is his inclusion as the 10th highest-ranked quarterback on the list, positioned above players like Jordan Love. This ranking suggests that despite a disappointing year marked by injuries and fluctuations in form, Prescott is still viewed as a premier quarterback heading into the upcoming season.
The debate over whether Prescott truly belongs in the top 10 or even top 15 quarterbacks continues among fans and analysts alike. Many skeptics doubt his ability to maintain consistency, but lists such as Prisco’s provide validation to those who believe Prescott’s proven skills in regular-season play warrant such recognition. His critics, or haters as sometimes referenced, will likely use the ranking for further debate, yet Prescott himself appears unfazed by external opinions.
Evaluating Prescott’s Standing Amid Doubts and Support
The mixed opinions surrounding Prescott hinge largely on his performance consistency and injury history. While his track record in the playoffs invites criticism, his regular-season outputs have often been strong enough to keep him in conversations about elite quarterbacks. The inclusion of only 11 quarterbacks in Prisco’s top 100 list, with Prescott at number 10, highlights that despite past setbacks, he is still counted among the NFL’s upper echelon.
Analysts and rivals continue to watch Prescott carefully, noting that his experience and leadership remain valuable assets for the Cowboys’ offense. His ability to bounce back after injuries could be pivotal in shaping both his individual legacy and the team’s success in 2025. The ranking by Prisco suggests patience from some experts who expect Prescott to regain much of his previous form.
The NFL landscape is competitive, and quarterbacks like Jordan Love provide ongoing challenges for Prescott’s place among the best. Still, as the new season approaches, Dallas Cowboys fans and observers alike will be eager to see whether Prescott can silence doubters with consistent performances that reaffirm his status among football’s elite.