The 2025 MLB All-Star Game is scheduled for next month at Truist Park, with catchers Will Smith and Cal Raleigh topping the vote counts in their leagues. While Smith continues to be recognized as an elite all-around catcher, Raleigh is delivering what many consider the most impressive offensive season ever recorded by a catcher in Major League Baseball.
Cal Raleigh’s Record-Breaking Offensive Stats
Raleigh, playing for the Seattle Mariners, is batting .276/.383/.659 with 31 home runs and 66 RBIs over 75 games. His power at the plate has allowed him to surpass legends like Mickey Mantle, José Ramírez, and Lance Berkman for the most home runs by a switch-hitter before the All-Star break. His numbers place him at the forefront of historic offensive catcher performances in the sport.
Dave Roberts’ Endorsement of Will Smith’s Overall Game
Despite Raleigh’s offensive achievements, Los Angeles Dodgers manager Dave Roberts favors Will Smith as the premier catcher in baseball. Roberts emphasizes Smith’s comprehensive skill set, highlighting his clutch hitting, strong throwing, and leadership with pitchers. Roberts explained,
“So that’s for me. And I think the consistency. I think Will has done it for four years, something like that, and performed at a high level.”
Will Smith’s Strong 2025 Season and Defensive Leadership
Smith himself is performing exceptionally well this season. Leading the National League with a .328 batting average and a .425 on-base plus slugging percentage, he has tallied 15 doubles, one triple, nine home runs, and 42 RBIs in 62 games. Beyond offense, Smith is also respected for his game-calling skills, which add significant value to his defensive role behind the plate. Meanwhile, Raleigh’s defensive credentials include winning the American League Platinum Glove Award last year.
Roberts Praises Will Smith’s Resilience and Performance
Following a limited 2024 season due to a left ankle injury, Will Smith is making a strong comeback. Roberts expressed pride in Smith’s progress, stating,
“Going through the injuries and never making an excuse for it, but now he’s healthy, he’s strong. You can see it in the batter’s box and behind the plate. He’s really performing. I’ve always had the utmost confidence in Will as a ballplayer.”
Roberts acknowledged Raleigh’s talent as well, noting,
“He’s going to be the starter in the All-Star Game, and he’s just a talented, young ballplayer.”
Looking Ahead to the All-Star Showdown
The forthcoming MLB All-Star Game will showcase two of the best catchers in the league, each excelling in different facets of the game. While Cal Raleigh’s historic power and offensive production have drawn wide attention, Dave Roberts’ choice of Will Smith highlights the importance of consistency, leadership, and all-around skills in evaluating catchers. Fans can expect an exciting display of talent from both players that could impact their careers and team success moving forward.