The San Francisco Giants have optioned infielder Tyler Fitzgerald to their Triple-A affiliate in Sacramento, clearing a roster spot for veteran pitcher Justin Verlander, who was reinstated from the paternity list. This roster adjustment underscores shifting dynamics for Fitzgerald compared to his strong 2024 performance and raises questions about the team’s infield alignment moving forward.
Fitzgerald’s 2024 Success Contrasted with 2025 Struggles
Last season, Fitzgerald displayed impressive offensive and defensive versatility, hitting 15 home runs over 96 games while maintaining a slash line of .280/.334/.497 and a weighted runs created plus (wRC+) of 132. He also contributed 17 stolen bases and played multiple positions, primarily shortstop. Entering 2025, the Giants brought in Willy Adames to man shortstop, positioning Fitzgerald as the regular second baseman.
Through April 2025, Fitzgerald upheld solid production at second base with a .284/.341/.432 line and a 119 wRC+. However, his momentum was interrupted by a left rib fracture that placed him on the injured list. Since returning from injury, Fitzgerald has struggled considerably offensively, registering a disappointing .186/.245/.227 batting line over 110 plate appearances.
Infield Role Adjustments Amid Fitzgerald’s Demotion
With Fitzgerald demoted to Triple-A for consistent playing time and to regain form, his absence creates openings on the Major League roster. The team is expected to share second base duties among Christian Koss, Brett Wisely, and Casey Schmitt. Schmitt currently covers third base due to an injury to Matt Chapman, further complicating the infield situation.
Koss and Wisely have yet to establish themselves at the big-league level, posting respective slash lines of .219/.269/.260 in 81 plate appearances and .212/.256/.312 across 415 trips to the plate. The Giants will closely monitor Fitzgerald’s progress in Sacramento and anticipate either his swift return to form or a healthy Chapman’s comeback, potentially reshaping the infield before the trade deadline in August.
Implications for Fitzgerald’s Career Timeline
This demotion may have consequences for Fitzgerald’s service time accumulation, arbitration status, and free agency prospects. Beginning 2025 with one full year of Major League service, Fitzgerald is on pace to reach two years after this season. However, to secure a full year of service time, he must return to the Giants’ roster promptly and remain active for the rest of the season, a critical factor given the 172-day threshold out of a 186-day season.
The Giants face decisions in the coming weeks about their infield composition and whether additional moves will be necessary to stabilize the team’s performance as the season progresses.