The Detroit Tigers have encountered setbacks recently, losing four of their last six games amid injury struggles and underwhelming performances. Jack Flaherty, the team’s expected number two starter, has faced criticism after allowing 18 runs over his last three outings, casting doubts on his readiness and effectiveness as a key pitcher for the Tigers’ future ambitions.
After joining Detroit this offseason from the Los Angeles Dodgers, where he contributed to their 2024 World Series Championship, Flaherty’s recent consistency has come into question. In his latest start against the Oakland Athletics, he pitched six innings, conceding three runs while walking four batters and striking out seven—a solid, but not dominant performance that left fans skeptical about his role on a potential World Series contender.
Detroit Fans Question Flaherty’s Role Amidst Performance Concerns
Following the game against the Athletics, Woodward Sports Network captured the mixed reaction from fans, asking,
“Jack Flaherty walks off to an ovation after 6 innings of 3-run ball with 4 walks and 7 strikeouts. Do you trust him as a No. 2 starter on a World Series team?”
Commenters expressed divided views, largely leaning toward doubt.
Some fans believe Flaherty’s current form makes him a less suitable fit for the number two starter spot. One fan noted,
A healthy Reese Olson and Casey Mize are ahead of him right now,
while another commented,
He’s a 4th rotation pitcher which is a great job to secure,
signaling a belief that Flaherty is better positioned deeper in the rotation. Others were more cautiously optimistic, with a fan advising,
But he will find his groove. I think he needs to work the top of the zone more,
acknowledging potential improvements.
Despite the majority casting doubt, some supporters pointed to his trusted role with the Dodgers as evidence of his capability. One fan mentioned,
I dunno the Dodgers seemed to trust him,
though this was outweighed by negative feedback. This reflects a conflicted fan base unsure if Flaherty currently has the fitness and form to serve as Detroit’s reliable number two starter.
Emerging Prospects Challenge Flaherty’s Standing in the Rotation
Compounding the concern over Flaherty’s fitness are rising Tigers pitchers such as Reese Olson and Casey Mize, who are viewed by many as ahead in form and potential. Their health and performance present viable alternatives for Detroit’s pitching staff, making the competition for the second starter spot more intense. This competition adds urgency to Flaherty’s need to prove he can handle the pressure expected of a top-tier starter aiming for postseason success.
The Tigers’ recent struggles highlight the challenges they face as they aim to build a roster capable of returning to World Series contention. Flaherty’s fitness and performance in the coming weeks will be critical, as Detroit fans watch closely to see if he can regain the command and consistency that helped bring him championship experience with Los Angeles.