The New York Yankees are confronting a critical decision regarding the placement of Jazz Chisholm Jr. this season, as his position at third base remains uncertain. While Chisholm has demonstrated strong defensive skills at second base with three outs above average, his performance at third base has fallen short, registering a negative two outs above average. This temporary move was prompted by DJ LeMahieu’s presence—a seasoned player whose declining range and reduced offensive impact have raised questions about his role moving forward.
Chisholm’s flexibility on the field is valuable, but the team’s growing need for a dependable third baseman signals a shift in strategy. Many within the Yankees organization believe that securing a natural third baseman would optimize the team’s defense and allow Chisholm to return to his preferred position. This adjustment would also enable LeMahieu to be utilized more selectively against left-handed pitchers, where he has shown more success historically.
Ryan McMahon Emerges as a Key Candidate to Strengthen Third Base
The Yankees’ search for a reliable third baseman has led them to consider Ryan McMahon of the Colorado Rockies, who is currently signed to a $70 million contract extension through 2027. McMahon’s defensive credentials are solid, with a plus-four outs above average rating at third base, positioning him as a strong candidate to improve the Yankees’ infield.
Offensively, McMahon has hovered around league average with an OPS+ just below or near the norm. This season, he holds a .728 OPS and has hit 12 home runs, numbers that suggest he could benefit from the hitter-friendly environment of Yankee Stadium. The shorter right field porch is expected to enhance his power-hitting potential, offering the Yankees an opportunity to unlock greater offensive output from the infielder.
Financial Challenges Could Influence Trade Decisions
Acquiring McMahon would involve significant financial considerations, as the Rockies appear motivated to move him partly due to salary relief. The Yankees would need to take on McMahon’s $16 million annual salary for the upcoming two seasons, a substantial commitment that complicates the possible trade. Balancing this investment against the potential on-field gains will be a critical factor in the Yankees’ decision-making process.
If successful, the move would not only fill a vital defensive gap but also allow the Yankees to deploy their players more strategically. Chisholm could settle back into second base, where his defensive skills are proven, while LeMahieu’s role could be specialized to maximize matchups at the plate. This shift would represent a strategic realignment aimed at improving both defensive efficiency and offensive balance.
Implications for the Yankees’ Season and Beyond
The Yankees currently stand at a crossroad in determining their infield composition, especially with Chisholm’s uncertain status at third base. Bringing in Ryan McMahon could be a pivotal move that reshapes the team’s defensive setup and addresses a key area of need. As the trade deadline nears, the choices made by the organization will have lasting effects on their competitive position throughout the remainder of the season and the franchise’s future direction.
Decisions involving player deployment, positional stability, and financial investment will be decisive in navigating this critical period. The Yankees’ ability to integrate a player like McMahon while optimizing existing talents like Chisholm and LeMahieu will be closely watched by fans and analysts alike, marking an important chapter in the team’s pursuit of sustained success.