Yankees slugger Aaron Judge is having one of the most impressive seasons of his career in 2025, boasting a .354 batting average, 28 home runs, and 215 total bases through 82 games. With Sunday’s MLB prop picks featuring Judge’s total bases over/under set at 1.5, bettors eyeing Aaron Judge MLB prop picks should strongly consider the over at -120 odds, as he has recorded at least two total bases in 49 games this year.
Sunday’s MLB schedule offers many opportunities for players looking to maximize their bets through player props. Online sportsbooks provide a wide range of prop options for every game, with SportsLine’s advanced computer model running 10,000 simulations per contest to uncover the most promising bets. This model has been successful this season, particularly with home run props, achieving over 21 units of profit and maintaining a 41-32 record on top-rated MLB picks. The latest player prop projections offer intriguing value for Sunday’s matchups.
Why Aaron Judge Over 1.5 Total Bases Is a Strong Bet
The current MLB prop odds give the over 1.5 total bases bet on Aaron Judge a 54.6% chance of success. However, Judge’s performance suggests better odds, as he has surpassed 1.5 total bases in nearly 60% of his games this season. Notably, Judge was dominant against Athletics starter Luis Severino on May 11, going 4-for-5 with a double, demonstrating his ability to produce significant hitting against the opposing pitcher scheduled for Sunday. SportsLine’s projections estimate Judge will tally about 2.4 total bases in the game, making this bet an attractive option for bettors. The top sportsbook offering this wager at the best odds is BetMGM, which also provides first-time users potential bonus bets up to $1,500 if the initial wager does not win.
Other Baseball Player Props Worth Watching for Sunday
Besides Judge, several other player props show promise on Sunday’s slate. Jonathan Cannon of the White Sox, a 24-year-old third-round draft pick from Georgia in 2022, is projected to record over 3.5 strikeouts at +124 odds. Cannon has a career 4.55 ERA across 188 innings, averaging 7.2 strikeouts per nine innings while typically lasting over five innings per outing. He has exceeded four strikeouts in three of his last four starts and has gone over on strikeout props in 8 of his last 14 appearances. SportsLine’s model forecasts 4.4 strikeouts for Cannon in his upcoming game against the Giants, adding further confidence in this pick.
Additionally, Atlanta Braves pitcher Spencer Strider faces a challenging day against the Philadelphia Phillies. Returning from Tommy John surgery earlier this year, Strider has struggled with consistency, posting a 4.07 ERA over eight starts with at least two earned runs allowed in five of those games. The Phillies rank 10th in baseball for runs scored, and SportsLine projects Strider to surrender about 2.7 earned runs on Sunday. The best odds for this prop (over 1.5 earned runs at -154) are currently offered by Caesars Sportsbook, which features a promotion allowing users to double winnings on their next 10 bets after an initial $1 wager.
Additional Resources and Expert Picks for Sunday’s Games
For bettors seeking further insight, SportsLine provides comprehensive MLB player prop projections covering every game on Sunday. Industry experts such as Bruce Marshall, who is 26-23-1 with a +554 profit over his last 50 MLB picks, and Jacob Fetner offer valuable selections to help bettors make informed decisions. Matt Severance, another top SportsLine analyst boasting a 171-100 record (+1381 units) across 271 MLB picks, has also released his recommended plays for the day, making these analyses a useful resource for those looking to capitalize on Sunday’s contests.
With Aaron Judge’s remarkable season and his strong matchup against Luis Severino, betting on Judge’s over 1.5 total bases prop appears poised to deliver significant value this Sunday. Along with other promising player props like Cannon’s strikeouts and Strider’s earned runs, these selections highlight opportunities for bettors to leverage data-driven insights and sportsbook promotions for potentially lucrative returns.