Dallas Cowboys ownership recently received a projection on offensive lineman Tyler Smith’s upcoming contract extension that they hope is inaccurate. Smith, who is entering his fourth season with the team, has more than lived up to his status as a first-round draft pick in 2022, already earning All-Pro honors by age 24 and establishing himself as one of the NFL’s top guards. The team exercised his fifth-year option last month, locking him in through the 2026 season, where he is set to earn approximately $21.27 million.
Given Smith’s consistent performance and durability, the Cowboys clearly have more ambitious plans for him beyond 2026. Sources project that if Smith maintains his current level of play, he could become the highest-paid offensive lineman in league history, with his contract potentially exceeding $20 million annually. His physical presence and ability to sustain a high volume of snaps make him a cornerstone of the Cowboys’ offensive line moving forward.
Current Contract Estimates Appear to Undervalue Smith’s Market Worth
Despite optimistic projections, some official estimates paint a less favorable financial picture. According to Spotrac, Smith’s next extension is projected at $76 million over four years, averaging about $19 million per season. While this might seem substantial, it actually undercuts his true market value, especially given that his fifth-year option for 2026 already guarantees him $21.27 million.
Additionally, if Smith remains unsigned by 2027, the franchise tag for an offensive lineman is anticipated to surpass $28 million, making it financially unwise for Smith to accept the estimated $19 million per year extension. As it stands, his base salary in 2025 is slated to be $2.5 million, which is significantly less than what his proven play might command.
Implications for Smith and the Cowboys Moving Forward
Tyler Smith, a 6-foot-6, 330-pound lineman from Fort Worth and Tulsa, has not yet reached his physical prime, suggesting his potential earnings could escalate further. The possibility of nearly $50 million guaranteed over two years through the fifth-year option and franchise tag highlights why Smith is unlikely to settle for a contract that undervalues his contributions.
The Cowboys face the strategic necessity of negotiating a deal that reflects Smith’s elite status and helps secure his presence on the roster long term. This season will be critical for Smith to solidify his standing as a top-three guard in the NFL, potentially strengthening his bargaining position in any upcoming contract discussions.
Dallas Cowboys’ Broader Outlook and Team Context
While Smith’s contract situation develops, the Cowboys continue to build around key players like quarterback Dak Prescott, whose success in dominating the NFC East fuels the team’s division-winning aspirations. Ensuring that rising stars like Smith remain part of the team’s future is essential for Dallas’ continued competitiveness.