Aaron Rodgers’ arrival as a Pittsburgh Steeler has lasted just under two weeks, but his appearance in the team’s black and gold uniform has already sparked widespread reaction. Fans and critics quickly shared their opinions after the first images of the multiple-time MVP in Steelers gear were revealed on Tuesday, generating significant online backlash about his new look.
Fan Reactions to Rodgers’ Steelers Uniform and Number Choice
The initial photos of Aaron Rodgers donning the Steelers colors prompted immediate mockery from some fans. The criticism ranged from comments on his appearance to disapproval of his transition to Pittsburgh, showing the intensity of opinion surrounding the move.
“Insanely lame tattoos sighting,” one reported.
“Never seen someone look more washed,” another marveled.
“Get gramps off the league man smh,” another implored.
“He should’ve took 12 just to piss certain people off,” one insisted.
“This looks so wrong,” another shuddered.
Rodgers will sport number 8 with the Steelers, a nod to both his college days at California (Berkeley) and his recent stint with the New York Jets. He cannot wear his familiar number 12, which is retired by the Jets in honor of Joe Namath and has been unused in Pittsburgh since Terry Bradshaw’s retirement in 1983, although it is not officially retired by the Steelers.
Legacy and Criticism from Steelers Legend Terry Bradshaw
Terry Bradshaw, a Hall of Fame quarterback for Pittsburgh, publicly criticized the Steelers’ decision to pursue Rodgers. Speaking on 103.7 The Buzz in late May, Bradshaw expressed skepticism about the signing as a long-term solution.
“What are you gonna do? Bring him in for one year, are you kidding me? That guy needs to stay in California. Go somewhere and chew on bark and whisper to the gods out there.”
Bill Cowher Calls for Offensive Freedom for Aaron Rodgers
Former Steelers head coach Bill Cowher emphasized the importance of offensive autonomy for Rodgers to maximize his effectiveness in Pittsburgh. Speaking on Dan Patrick’s show, Cowher highlighted the need for a balanced offense that supports Rodgers while allowing him control during critical moments.
“I don’t think there’s any question about it… I think in the meantime you create a balance on your football team that you’re not just relying on his arm throughout the course of four quarters.
“You can turn the ball over to him at the end of a half (or) at the end of a game and know he’s been there before, and I think he will operate that very, very efficiently. Again, I think it’s going to be a matter of getting comfortable in this system with the players he has around him.”
Supporting Rodgers in the 2025 season will be a somewhat rebuilt offense. Running back Jaylen Warren is stepping into a larger role after three years behind Najee Harris. Wide receiver DK Metcalf is expected to lead the receiving corps following George Pickens‘ exit, and the team recently traded for tight end Jonnu Smith from the Miami Dolphins to bolster the unit alongside Pat Freiermuth.
Looking Ahead to the Steelers’ 2025 Season Opener
The Steelers will commence their new season on September 7 against Rodgers’ former team, the New York Jets. The kickoff is scheduled for 1 pm on CBS, marking the beginning of a highly anticipated campaign filled with questions about how well Rodgers will integrate into the black and gold offense.
The intense reactions to Aaron Rodgers Steelers debut look reflect the high stakes and pressures facing him in Pittsburgh. His success hinges not only on his performance but also on how well the coaching staff adapts to his style and leverages the talents around him. Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see if Rodgers can silence critics and lead the Steelers into a new competitive era.