As the 2025 season continues, Cal Raleigh and Aaron Judge have emerged as the front-runners for the American League MVP award, capturing significant attention with their outstanding performances. While Judge is a two-time MVP winner, Raleigh is making a strong case with the best offensive season of his career combined with exceptional defense behind the plate.
Defensive Excellence Gives Raleigh an Advantage, Says Insider
In a recent discussion on the Pinstripe Post, Joel Sherman highlighted the unique defensive challenges that catchers face today, suggesting that Raleigh’s role as a catcher provides him with a distinct edge over Judge in the MVP race. Sherman emphasized how modern catchers are expected to manage a complex array of responsibilities that exceed what legendary players like Johnny Bench, Buster Posey, and Pudge Rodriguez once handled.
“What Cal Raleigh is doing is almost MVP worthy, even over Aaron Judge,” Sherman said. “Because what we’re asking catchers to do in 2025 is so much greater than what Johnny Bench had to do, even what Buster Posey had to do and what Pudge Rodriguez had to do.”
“The amount of information retention that these guys have to have today, and the stuff they’re dealing with, the velo and the movement, at a greater level than ever. The burden is so great on these guys.”
Raleigh’s Power Numbers Surpass Judge’s
Cal Raleigh stands out not only for his defensive abilities but also for his impressive offensive production. Currently, Raleigh leads the major leagues with 33 home runs, three more than Aaron Judge’s 30. This power display is a key factor in Raleigh’s rising reputation and positions him strongly as a valuable offensive force this season.
As the season reaches the mid-point, Raleigh’s performance almost guarantees his first All-Star appearance. His ability to consistently deliver both with the bat and behind the plate makes him a vital pillar for the Seattle Mariners.
Raleigh’s Role in Seattle’s Playoff Hopes
The Mariners, seeking postseason success for just the third time since 2000, rely heavily on Raleigh’s contributions. His adept management of pitching and defensive duties combined with his clutch hitting fulfills the dual demands expected from top-tier catchers today. Mariners fans remain hopeful that Raleigh’s hot streak continues throughout the second half, boosting the team’s chances to secure a postseason berth.
Cal Raleigh’s growing presence in the 2025 AL MVP race not only showcases his individual breakout but also reflects the increasing importance of versatile catchers who combine power and defense at unprecedented levels.