The Boston Red Sox are navigating a difficult 2025 campaign, with the Trevor Story contract and Red Sox future at the center of ongoing speculation as the MLB draft draws near. Sitting in fourth place in the American League East, the team is wrestling with underwhelming results, injury woes, and concerns over their high-priced shortstop’s performance.
Season Challenges Dampen Early Optimism for Boston
Preseason expectations were high for the Red Sox, after an overhaul of their roster that blended promising prospects and free-agent additions with a new, youthful core. There was hope that these changes could end their four-year postseason absence. However, as the season progressed, inconsistent play and a series of setbacks—including lingering injury concerns and the unresolved Rafael Devers situation—have left the club in a challenging position at 43-45, well behind their division rivals.
While the season still offers a window for improvement, especially if prospects like Marcelo Mayer and Roman Anthony progress quickly, the Red Sox find themselves facing the reality of another disappointing campaign unless fortunes change dramatically.
Draft Hopes and Infield Questions Take Center Stage
As Boston approaches the upcoming MLB draft, there is growing attention on Bleacher Nation’s projection that the team may select Xavier Neyens, a third baseman from Mount Vernon High School in Washington. Neyens is recognized by scouts for his powerful left-handed bat, disciplined approach at the plate, and physical tools—standing 6-foot-4 with a strong throwing arm—making him a likely fit for the Major Leagues at third base.
This potential selection could bring more flexibility to the Red Sox infield, as the addition of Neyens might help the organization manage the financial and performance-related questions surrounding Trevor Story. Story, who is set to earn $22.5 million next season with a player opt-out, is unlikely to leave money on the table with two additional years at $25 million each still due, as well as a club option for 2028. Despite his contract, Story has struggled to produce at the level expected, batting just .244 with a .675 OPS over 84 games—a significant concern for the front office.
Bringing Neyens into the fold could also allow Marcelo Mayer to transition to his natural position of shortstop when the time comes. Mayer, currently considering attending Oregon State, has yet to make his MLB debut, but his eventual arrival is viewed as a hopeful development for a fan base looking for reasons to remain optimistic about the future.
Veteran Roster Moves and Trade Deadline Uncertainty
With the trade deadline approaching, some team veterans are reported to be pleading with management to avoid being traded, amplifying the uncertainty surrounding the direction of the franchise. Questions persist about potential moves the front office could make, including possible plans involving names like Alex Bregman. The outcome of these decisions may determine whether the Red Sox enter a full rebuild or continue seeking a fast turnaround.
What Awaits the Red Sox and Their Supporters
As Boston fans await draft results and await clarity on the Trevor Story contract and Red Sox future, hope hinges on the franchise’s chosen path—whether relying on rising stars such as Neyens and Mayer, or making major changes at the deadline. The coming months will be critical in shaping whether the team can escape its current rut and bring renewed energy to its loyal supporters at Fenway Park.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Is Trevor Story religious?
A. Two days following his contract signing with the Red Sox, Story and Crow had their first baby. Story practices the Christian faith.