The Boston Red Sox’s difficulties continue to grow as Trevor Story’s ongoing struggles, both at the plate and in the field, add pressure to a team already fighting to stay in playoff contention. Manager Alex Cora has expressed disappointment over key mistakes, with recent errors hurting the Red Sox in crucial games, a pattern affecting their postseason hopes and underlining the critical issue of Trevor Story Red Sox struggles.
Errors and Missed Opportunities Intensify Pressure
In a recent loss to the Cincinnati Reds, Boston squandered a 3-0 lead, with Trevor Story making a pivotal defensive mistake that contributed to an eventual 8-4 defeat. These lapses have led Alex Cora to make tough decisions, including removing Story from the lineup to address defensive issues. The manager made clear that these recurring mistakes are having a significant impact on the team’s season, particularly as costly errors continue to affect the Red Sox’s position in the standings.
“If you look back at the season, there’s been a lot of those that have slipped through our hands and honestly, we’re in the position where we are because of that,”
—Alex Cora, Manager
For a franchise expecting veteran leadership, the situation has grown more tense as these mistakes and inconsistencies compound over time, with Cora and the team searching for answers amid the mounting frustration.
Offensive Shortfalls Fuel Club’s Uncertainty
Story, who entered the 2025 season as a key piece in the Red Sox’s hopes for success, has not lived up to his contract so far. Signed for six years at $140 million, the shortstop’s production has been modest: a .244 batting average, 12 home runs, and 47 runs batted in. More concerning, his 100 strikeouts and low walk total of 16 by midseason point to difficulties with plate discipline, further increasing the team’s offensive woes.
With Rafael Devers already gone from the roster and rumors of Alex Bregman potentially being traded, Story’s performance has become even more vital. Originally meant to be an anchor alongside Devers and Bregman, the 32-year-old now faces heightened expectations to lead the charge on both offense and defense—expectations he has yet to meet.
Cora Searches for Answers While Playoff Hopes Hang by a Thread
Throughout the season, Alex Cora has tried various ways to help Story regain form, even suggesting brief periods of rest or a change of perspective. The manager hopes that these adjustments might have a positive effect on the struggling shortstop as the pressure ramps up.
“Maybe just kind of back up and watch the game from a different perspective… just relax and clear your mind. Hopefully that benefits him,”
—Alex Cora, Manager
With the Red Sox holding a 43-45 record, their chances for a playoff berth look increasingly slim unless a dramatic change occurs. As the team attempts to weather ongoing challenges and internal uncertainty, the tension continues to mount in the clubhouse. Boston’s leaders, including Alex Cora and Trevor Story, are under pressure to deliver before hopes of a postseason run slip away entirely.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Is Trevor Story healthy?
A. Since he came to Boston, he has struggled with injuries each season and has never played more than 94 games for the Red Sox.
This year, though, he has stayed healthy and has already played in 82 games. He is hitting .237, with 12 home runs and a .660 OPS.
Q. What surgery did Trevor Story have?
A. In April, Story had surgery to fix the back part of his shoulder labrum using a small camera and tools. The doctors also repaired a fracture on the edge of his shoulder socket by opening the area and securing the bone in place.
Q. Is Trevor Story religious?
A. Just two days after joining the Red Sox, Story and Crow had their first baby. Story follows the Christian faith.