Aaron Judge has established himself as a cornerstone for the New York Yankees, showcasing exceptional talent that aligns with the franchise’s rich history. Derek Jeter, a longtime Yankees icon, reflected on his initial meeting with Judge, highlighting moments that foretold the current captain’s rise. Their encounter took place nearly a decade ago at the Yankees’ Captain’s Camp in Tampa, Florida, where Judge was then a minor league player.
Jeter spent dinner with Judge and other prospects during the camp, an event designed to foster leadership qualities among the team’s future stars. After Judge’s appointment as Yankees captain in 2022, Jeter shared his early impressions of the young player and the respect he commanded even in those early stages.
First Impressions: Size and Quiet Respect Made Aaron Judge Stand Out
Jeter recalled that the very first thing noticeable about Judge was his imposing stature, a rarity for baseball players.
“His size was the first thing that stands out, because you don’t see too many baseball players that size,”
—Derek Jeter
Jeter went on to describe the atmosphere at the camp, noting that most players remained quiet, but Judge distinguished himself through his respectful attention and engagement.
“Everyone at the camp was kind of quiet; they don’t say too much. But you could tell he was respectful. You can tell if people are paying attention.”
—Derek Jeter
He further took ownership of Judge’s leadership trajectory.
“You could tell that he was listening, and I take all responsibility now for him being captain,”
—Derek Jeter
Judge’s Performance Continues to Solidify His Role in Yankees History
In the 2025 season, Aaron Judge has underscored his value to the Yankees with outstanding numbers, including a .365 batting average and 32 home runs in 323 at-bats. His outstanding performance has placed him among the top contenders for the MVP award, confirming his impact on the team’s success and his legacy within the franchise.
Comparisons to Derek Jeter: A Humble Leader’s Perspective
During Judge’s breakout rookie season in 2017, he earned the American League Rookie of the Year award. At that time, former Yankees manager Joe Girardi drew parallels between the young Judge and Derek Jeter, sparking discussions about their comparable leadership and playing styles. Despite these comparisons, Judge maintained a modest stance.
When questioned about resembling the Yankees’ legendary shortstop, Judge acknowledged the compliment but focused on forging his own path.
“There’s only one Derek Jeter. It’s a great compliment. Honored to be in the same sentence, but I’m just trying to go out there and be the best Aaron Judge I can be.”
—Aaron Judge
Judge’s humility did not diminish his own growing stature within the Yankees organization. Becoming the first captain since Jeter further confirms his integral role in the team’s ongoing narrative.
Legacy and Leadership: What Lies Ahead for Aaron Judge
Derek Jeter’s reflections and Aaron Judge’s continued excellence highlight the enduring values of respect, leadership, and dedication that define the Yankees. As Judge builds on his promising career, he carries forward a legacy shaped in part by Jeter’s mentorship and example. The connection between past and present captains reinforces the strength of the franchise’s identity, suggesting that Judge’s leadership will remain influential in the years to come.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Why is Aaron Judge so special?
A. Aaron Judge is famous for hitting home runs. He has achieved three seasons with 50 or more, making him one of only five players to do so.
Q. Does Aaron Judge know his biological parents?
A. He shared with The Post, “I believe they chose me, like it was God who brought us together.” Aaron Judge was adopted through a closed adoption, so he has never been in touch with his birth parents. He also mentions he’s never felt the need to meet them.
Q. What is so special about Aaron Judge?
A. He is just the 20th player on his team in the first 28 games to get on base 63 times and bring in 27 runs. Only one other player has done this in the last 23 years, and that was Bryce Harper in 2017. Judge is famous for holding the American League record for the most home runs in a single season. He is also the quickest player to reach 300 home runs.
Q. Can Aaron Judge grow a beard?
A. Aaron Judge has stated he will not grow a beard, even with the Yankees’ new rule allowing facial hair.