The Los Angeles Dodgers face a significant challenge as Max Muncy will be sidelined for the foreseeable future, prompting the team to consider potential trades to fill the void. One prime target is Ryan McMahon, the Colorado Rockies’ third baseman, who could provide a short-term and long-term solution for the Dodgers’ infield needs.

Linked in rumors, the Dodgers might exchange starting pitcher Dustin May in a deal that aims to reinforce their lineup. McMahon, a dependable member of the struggling Rockies roster, remains under contract through 2025 at $12 million per year, offering the Dodgers stability beyond Muncy’s recovery.

Reasons Behind the Dodgers’ Interest in Ryan McMahon

The Rockies, who currently hold the worst record in Major League Baseball at 21–71, are open to offers for McMahon, attracting attention from teams like the New York Yankees seeking an upgrade at third base. Muncy’s injury, sidelining him for an estimated six weeks, has created an urgent infield gap for Los Angeles, making McMahon a viable option despite his mixed 2023 statistics.

Although McMahon’s batting line stands at .210/.310/.373 with 117 strikeouts—leading the National League—his defensive proficiency at third base is valuable. His presence would enable utility player Tommy Edman to continue splitting duties between second base and center field, benefiting the team’s flexibility on the diamond.

Zachary Howell of Clutch Points highlighted McMahon’s potential contributions, stating,

“He can still produce in the field and at the plate,”

and

“Los Angeles does not need much from McMahon, but he is a far better option at third than Tommy Edman.”

With a career .740 OPS, McMahon could seamlessly join the Dodgers’ potent lineup without becoming a central focus for opposing pitchers. The Dodgers also maintain a club option on Muncy after this season, suggesting that acquiring McMahon might support both immediate needs and a younger offensive presence extending beyond 2025.

Howell further noted,

“His contract also gives the Dodgers plenty of control after the end of this season,”

adding,

“In the short-term, the veteran infielder can spell Muncy while he recovers and pick up his slack in the heart of Roberts’ order.”

Factors Influencing the Dodgers’ Willingness to Trade Dustin May

Dustin May, a 27-year-old starting pitcher, is a key piece the Dodgers could offer in exchange for McMahon. However, May is approaching free agency after the 2025 season and has had an uneven year, owning a 5-5 record with a 4.52 ERA and a 1.31 WHIP over 16 starts.

Despite the recent Tommy John surgery setback, May had begun the 2023 season strongly, posting a 4-1 record with a 2.63 ERA and a WHIP under 1.00 in nine occurrences before going down. As injured players like Tyler Glasnow and Blake Snell near their comebacks and Shohei Ohtani resumes pitching, May may face increased competition for rotation spots.

A one-for-one deal involving May might not suffice to secure McMahon, especially considering May’s contract status and age, meaning the Dodgers could have to include additional assets to close the trade.

Zachary Howell explained Colorado’s perspective on accepting a player like May, remarking,

“On a team building for the future, only one of their starters is younger than 30 years old.”

He underscored the value of starting pitching in today’s game, especially at hitter-friendly Coors Field, pointing out the Rockies’ challenging outlook.

Howell elaborated,

“The Rockies should take a chance on May this season. His contract is a cheap one-year deal, making it imperative for Colorado to re-sign him this winter before another team snaps him up. However, giving him a half season in their system could help the Rockies convince him to sign a long-term deal and lead their rotation.”

Implications of a McMahon Acquisition for the Dodgers

If the Dodgers move forward with acquiring Ryan McMahon, they would effectively address the immediate gap left by Max Muncy’s injury while potentially securing a younger but experienced infielder for the near future. McMahon’s defensive skills and moderate offensive production aim to stabilize the lineup without placing excessive pressure on the team’s offensive core.

The Dodgers would also demonstrate adaptability in navigating roster management through injuries among key players, balancing pitching depth and infield coverage in a competitive National League West division.

The potential trade also signals a strategic shift for both franchises: the Rockies would gain a younger starting pitcher in May who might be foundational in rebuilding, while the Dodgers aim to maintain their postseason momentum despite setbacks in their roster.

Our Reader’s Queries

Q. Why is Max Muncy on the disabled list?

A. On Thursday, Max Muncy was put on the 10-day injured list. This happened a day after he left a game due to a concerning on-field collision. He and the Dodgers felt relieved when doctors confirmed he had only a bone bruise in his left knee instead of a season-ending injury.

Q. What is Max Muncy’s annual salary?

A. Considered one of the best footballers ever, Messi achieved many records in his career. He won eight Ballon d’Ors and six European Golden Shoes. Additionally, FIFA named him the world’s best player eight times.