Pete Alonso, the New York Mets’ celebrated slugger, shocked the baseball world by opting out of the 2025 Home Run Derby despite securing a spot as an All-Star and mounting a strong season comeback. Known for his commanding presence and previous Derby triumphs, Alonso’s decision to forgo the event caught both fans and Mets manager Carlos Mendoza off guard, signaling a shift in his priorities toward October’s playoff push.
Alonso’s choice stems from a desire to concentrate on his performance for the Mets’ crucial second half, rather than the spectacle of the Derby. This focus on team success rather than individual accolades has intrigued many observers. The Mets’ skipper initially expected Alonso to take part but later respected the player’s dedication to the larger goal.
Manager Mendoza’s Reaction: Respect for Alonso’s Dedication
Mets manager Carlos Mendoza expressed his surprise and understanding during a candid conversation with Todd Frazier on Foul Territory. Though taken aback at first by Alonso’s withdrawal, Mendoza acknowledged the slugger’s intense preparation and mission-oriented mentality this season.
“I thought he was gonna do it. When they told me he was an All-Star, in my head I was like, ‘Alright, he’s doing the Home Run Derby.’ And then when I found out that he wasn’t, I was like, ‘Hmm,’”
the manager said.
Mendoza added,
“But watching him this year with the way he’s preparing, how meticulous he is, the guy’s on a mission. So I’m not surprised. He felt it was best for him and for the team, and I respect that.”
His respect for Alonso’s choice was reiterated emphatically, underlining the mutual trust between player and coach.
Alonso’s Reasoning: Prioritizing the Team Over Individual Spotlight
Alonso revealed that his absence from this year’s Derby was a deliberate move to ensure he remains in peak condition for the remainder of the season. Rather than fatigue or lack of enthusiasm, his decision reflects a strategic standpoint on career longevity and team contribution.
“I just decided not to do it this year,”
Alonso said.
“I’ve never really fully enjoyed the three off-days, so I just want to be in the best possible position to help this team win in the second half.”
His current season performance showcases no decline; with a batting slash line at .290/.383/.934, Alonso remains a formidable force at the plate, reinforcing that his choice is forward-looking rather than reactionary.
Legacy at the Derby and What’s Next for Alonso
With two Home Run Derby titles in 2019 and 2021, alongside a semi-final run in 2022, Alonso has been a central figure in the event’s recent history. His competitive spirit and showmanship transformed the Derby into a must-watch spectacle for fans and competitors alike.
Despite his break from this year’s event, Alonso made it clear that this is temporary. He intends to return when the timing aligns with his goals and team commitments.
“I love the event. It’s a sick event,”
he shared.
“I definitely will do it again. It doesn’t mean ‘No’ forever. I figure I’ll take a break.”
In Alonso’s absence, emerging sluggers like Ronald Acuña Jr. from Atlanta, Cal Raleigh of Seattle, and Washington’s James Wood are expected to captivate audiences with their power displays. Yet the Derby stage remains open for Alonso’s eventual return.
A New Chapter for the Mets’ Star and Team Leadership
Alonso’s decision to sideline himself from the Derby reflects a deeper leadership evolution, focusing his energy on driving the Mets toward a successful postseason. His commitment to October goals over midseason fanfare resonates as a significant symbol for the team’s ambitions.
Mendoza’s initial surprise has given way to a clear alignment with Alonso’s vision, signaling a supportive environment for the slugger’s determined playoff push. As the Mets enter the season’s critical phase, Alonso’s choice may well serve as a catalyst for the clubhouse’s focus and resilience.
Ultimately, Alonso skipping the Home Run Derby is less about stepping back and more about stepping forward—aiming for lasting impact when the stakes are highest.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Why do they call Pete Alonso a polar bear?
A. During the 2019 spring training, Alonso, considered a leading prospect, stood out. Todd Frazier, a former third baseman known for his personality, gave him the nickname. Frazier remarked, “In Spring Training, you resembled a big, polar bear.”
Q. Why is Pete Alonso called a polar bear?
A. Alonso earned his “Polar Bear” nickname while he was a highly regarded prospect. In spring training 2019, he stood out so much that Todd Frazier, the Mets third baseman famous for creating nicknames, called him “Polar Bear.” Frazier remarked to Alonso, “You resemble a big polar bear.”