After his two-home run performance against the Mariners on Wednesday night, Jazz Chisholm Jr. sent a clear message to those who doubted him, highlighting his strong impact for the New York Yankees. The Jazz Chisholm Jr overrated poll response has been undeniable, especially considering his recent surge in offensive production.
Last June, The Athletic conducted a player poll naming Chisholm the “Most Overrated Player in MLB,” a label that fans and analysts cited with skepticism. One fan on X.com resurfaced that poll after Wednesday’s game, sharing Chisholm’s impressive stats since that time:
144 G / 607 PA · .257/.336/.477 · 32 HR / 38 SB · 5.3 fWAR
—The Athletic player poll
Chisholm responded by simply liking and retweeting the post without adding a comment, letting his performance speak for itself. His numbers since returning from the injured list on June 3 only strengthened his case, posting a .315 batting average with a .378/.614 slash line, seven homers, and 19 RBIs throughout June, plus five more home runs in early July.
This season, he is hitting .251/.346/.530 with an .876 OPS, tallying 17 home runs, 43 RBIs, and 10 steals across 61 games. Since returning, Chisholm has been the Yankees’ hottest hitter, significantly exceeding his previous output with a .247/.344/.502 line before the injury.
Besides statistics, his presence in the clubhouse has gained attention. Known for his expressive style and high energy on the field, Chisholm’s approach seems to have found acceptance within the Yankees’ team culture, despite sometimes polarizing other players around the league. Assistant hitting coach Casey Dykes was seen sharing a light moment with Chisholm in the dugout, illustrating his positive integration.
His contribution goes well beyond flair, affecting the Yankees’ lineup and boosting their offensive strength at a critical time. Earning his second All-Star selection, and first as a Yankee, validates his value and progress.
The “overrated” tag from a year ago no longer fits as Chisholm continues to respond with consistent power and speed, reinforcing his place among the league’s key performers. This redemption story highlights how perseverance and performance can overturn past doubts.
With the stretch he has delivered so far this season, Jazz Chisholm Jr. is poised to remain a vital figure for the Yankees, and his recent achievements set a foundation for continued impact as the season advances.