As the MLB trade deadline approaches, speculation surrounds the Boston Red Sox and the possibility of an Alex Bregman Red Sox trade. Numerous teams have shown interest in acquiring Bregman, but the Red Sox front office, led by Craig Breslow, remains under significant pressure to decide the player’s future. Despite the rumors, a trusted MLB insider firmly believes that trading Bregman is highly unlikely.
Ken Rosenthal’s Perspective on Why Trading Bregman Doesn’t Add Up
Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic has voiced his strong opinion on the matter, emphasizing that the idea of trading Bregman does not align with Boston’s current position or plans. Rosenthal argues that even if the Red Sox fail to secure an extension with Bregman before the deadline or struggle during a challenging upcoming stretch of games, moving him would still be illogical.
“For the Red Sox, trading Bregman makes no sense,”
Rosenthal states.
“Even if they cannot sign him to an extension before the deadline, even if they stumble while facing a difficult schedule over the next three weeks.”
With a winning record and a realistic shot at the postseason, Rosenthal asserts that the Red Sox should hold onto Bregman. The third baseman’s ability to improve Boston’s lineup and contribute to a potential playoff run in 2025 outweighs the risks of losing him to free agency.
The Value and Risks of Trading Bregman at This Time
Bregman’s presence in the lineup offers considerable upside, but any trade would require the right compensation. Since Bregman could choose to opt out and become a free agent after this season, the Red Sox would likely receive less value in return compared to his actual worth on the field. This consideration makes a trade more complicated and less appealing for Boston.
Rosenthal underscores the improbability of a trade by offering a colorful comparison about the situation’s rarity:
“You’d sooner see a certain 5-foot-4 reporter (Rosenthal) in a bow tie dunking on the 7-foot-3 Victor Wembanyama.”
—Ken Rosenthal, MLB Insider
This hyperbolic imagery highlights just how remote Rosenthal believes an Alex Bregman Red Sox trade really is, reinforcing his stance that it is unlikely to happen under any foreseeable circumstances.
Current Team Momentum Affirms Bregman’s Position in Boston
The Red Sox are currently riding a seven-game winning streak, and Bregman is nearing a return to the active roster, which improves Boston’s chances of competing for a top Wild Card spot in the American League. Given this upward trajectory, trading Bregman would conflict with the team’s postseason aspirations.
Unless Boston’s record drops significantly or urgent roster concerns arise, retaining Bregman remains the logical choice. The team’s competitive state means that trading one of its key contributors at this point would be counterproductive.
Outlook for the Red Sox and Bregman Moving Forward
In the coming weeks, with the trade deadline imminent, the Red Sox will need to carefully evaluate their options. Rosenthal’s insights suggest that keeping Bregman is the wisest course of action for a team on the playoff bubble. Boston’s decision will affect both its postseason hopes and its final roster composition for the remainder of the season.
Ultimately, the Alex Bregman Red Sox trade appears to be more rumor than reality, with insiders warning against making a move that could hinder Boston’s chances in the short term and beyond.