The New York Yankees face a pressing issue at third base as they head into the 2025 season. With Oswaldo Cabrera sidelined since May and Jazz Chisholm Jr. moving back to his usual position at second base, the team now must find a reliable option to fill this important spot. The discussion around potential solutions has intensified, with Ryan McMahon emerging as a potential fit for the Yankees.
Third Base Challenges After Cabrera and Chisholm’s Position Shift
Following Cabrera’s departure due to injury, Chisholm stepped in at third base but is set to return to second base, creating uncertainty about who will man third. While the Yankees have several candidates, none have firmly established themselves as the clear solution. This dilemma leaves the team searching for a dependable third baseman before the new season begins.
Mike Francesa Endorses Ryan McMahon as a Cost-Effective Answer
Veteran sports radio host Mike Francesa proposed Ryan McMahon as a smart, economical choice to address New York’s third base problem. Speaking on his podcast, Francesa acknowledged McMahon’s struggles this year but emphasized his defensive skills and offensive potential suited for Yankee Stadium.
“I know he’s (Ryan McMahon) had a terrible year, but wouldn’t you? I know he’s given up, and he’s not doing anything in Colorado now. But, Colorado will give him away now. They wouldn’t in the past, they will now.” —Mike Francesa, Sports Broadcaster
“He can defend, he’s got a Yankee Stadium swing, they can get him on the cheap. I don’t want to spend a lot for a guy I trust at the position. I would get this guy on the cheap, bring him in, and he’s got a Yankee Stadium Swing and he plays defense. I think he’ll be highly motivated. I would take a chance on him. Plus, he’s not even 30 years old.” —Mike Francesa, Sports Broadcaster
Despite a difficult 2025 season where McMahon carries only a .208 batting average, 12 home runs, and 26 RBIs, his previous All-Star appearance in 2024 signals that he still possesses the talent to contribute. Meanwhile, his current team, the Colorado Rockies, are struggling dramatically with a 21-72 record, putting McMahon in a position where a trade is plausible.
Other Potential Third Base Targets Highlighted by MLB Analysts
MLB insider Jon Heyman recently commented on Chisholm’s return to second base and noted the Yankees would actively pursue a reliable third baseman this offseason. Besides McMahon, he named players like Luis Rengifo and Isiah Kiner-Falefa as potential internal options but pointed out that Eugenio Suárez from the Arizona Diamondbacks stands out as a premium target.
“Suárez makes around $15 million a year. To me, he’d be great for any team—even a team that’s over the top threshold and has to pay the 110% tax, as the Yankees would. I think he’d be great for the Yankees. I’m just not sure they’ll do the cash outlay it would take to get Suárez.” —Jon Heyman, MLB Insider
Suárez has had a solid 2025 campaign, batting .249 with 29 home runs and 75 RBIs over 338 at-bats. However, his salary demands might deter the Yankees from pursuing him aggressively, especially considering the luxury tax financial implications for New York.
What the Third Base Situation Means for the Yankees’ Future
The Yankees’ uncertainty at third base highlights a broader challenge of balancing competitive needs with financial constraints. Ryan McMahon represents a veteran player who could be acquired without a major cash investment and who fits the team‘s ballpark conditions well. His youth and prior success offer hope for a turnaround that could stabilize the position.
Conversely, pursuing a high-profile name like Eugenio Suárez comes with significant financial costs that might conflict with the Yankees’ budget strategies. The team’s decision will be crucial as they prepare to strengthen their infield and maintain their competitiveness in the coming seasons.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Who is Ryan McMahon?
A. McMahon entered the organization in 2013 after being picked 42nd overall in the MLB Draft from Mater Dei High School, Santa Ana, California, at 18. He played his first Major League game on August 12, 2017, when he was 22. Currently 30 years old, McMahon has been with the Rockies longer than any other player in the clubhouse.
Q. What did Ryan McMahon do?
A. For almost 20 years, Ryan McMahon has led the way in Indigenous comedy and storytelling. He aims to challenge norms and reshape his surroundings using humor and Indigenous tales.
Q. Is Ryan McMahon married?
A. In March 2022, McMahon agreed to a six-year contract worth $70 million with the Rockies and remains an important part of the team. Ryan married his long-time girlfriend, Natalie, in November 2020.