As the MLB trade deadline approaches, the St. Louis Cardinals find themselves at a critical juncture. Holding a 50-46 record, the team remains close to a playoff spot in the National League, leading the front office to carefully evaluate the roster and consider potential moves. Third baseman Nolan Arenado, whose future on the team remains uncertain, has attracted notable attention during these discussions.
Assessing Nolan Arenado’s Current Performance
Arenado’s name has been frequently mentioned in trade talks, especially because he still has two years of team control beyond this season. While he has been a key player for the Cardinals, his offensive numbers this year have caused concern. Despite his reputation as a strong hitter with the Colorado Rockies, Arenado’s 2024 statistics show a downturn, with 10 home runs and 41 RBIs across 81 games, reflecting a career-low level of production at the plate.
Karl Rasmussen of Sports Illustrated remarked on Arenado’s ongoing value, emphasizing his defensive strengths even as his hitting falters.
He may not be the slugger he was during his prime, but he’s still a gifted defensive third baseman who can flash some pop from time to time,
Rasmussen said, also noting Arenado’s .694 OPS is just below the league average of .715, suggesting the possibility for improvement despite the current slump.
New York Yankees Could Benefit From Arenado’s Defensive Skillset
The New York Yankees have emerged as a potential destination for Arenado due to their persistent issues at third base. The team has been using Jazz Chisholm Jr. outside of his natural position, resulting in instability within the lineup. Bringing in Arenado could fortify the Yankees’ infield defense and provide some offensive upside, even if Arenado is not currently at his peak hitting performance.
Trade negotiations involving Arenado have surfaced repeatedly since last offseason but have yet to come to fruition. With the deadline nearing, trading Arenado to the Yankees may offer the player a chance for a fresh start, while allowing the Cardinals to reshape their roster and plan for future seasons.
Implications of the Trade Deadline Decision for St. Louis and Arenado
The Cardinals’ choice about Nolan Arenado’s status at the trade deadline carries significant implications for the team’s trajectory. Moving Arenado could allow St. Louis to address roster needs and invest in long-term strategies. Conversely, retaining him could stabilize their defense as they compete for a playoff spot. For Arenado, a trade to the Yankees might reinvigorate his career, leveraging his defensive expertise to fill a critical gap on New York’s roster as the season progresses.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Is Nolan Arenado the best 3rd baseman ever?
A. Nolan Arenado is considered one of the best third basemen ever. DeRo believes he will be remembered in Cooperstown for sure. Arenado is among only seven MLB players with over 350 home runs and more than ten Gold Glove Awards.
Q. Has Nolan Arenado ever won a world series?
A. Arenado, a three-time All-Star and two-time Gold Glove winner, came third in the NL MVP voting in 2022. Although successful individually, the Cardinals never won a playoff series with him. Now, Arenado has a chance to aim for his first World Series victory before his career ends.