Though Josh Allen of the Buffalo Bills was named the NFL’s Most Valuable Player, Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes leads an ESPN insider poll ranking the league’s top players. Conducted among nearly 80 NFL executives and scouts, the survey reflects wide-ranging opinions on current player performances, placing Allen second behind Mahomes. Compiled by Jeremy Fowler, the poll highlights ongoing debates about elite quarterback status and the impact of individual contributions on team success.
A personnel executive in the NFC praised Allen’s consistency, saying,
“He’s answered every test. He makes fewer mistakes and takes care of the ball. The only thing left to do is win it all.”
—NFC Personnel Executive
Assessing Josh Allen’s Growth and Remaining Challenges
Allen has undeniably improved his game by reducing risky decisions, although he still occasionally makes baffling plays. An NFL evaluator observed,
“He’s still got that risk-taking to his game and the occasional head-scratching play, but he’s taking more calculated risks than wild risks, which is helping his overall play.”
—NFL Evaluator
This cautious approach marks Allen’s evolution and strengthens his performance, but his ultimate objective—a Super Bowl win—continues to elude him, underscoring the pressure on the quarterback to lead Buffalo Bills to the sport’s highest achievement.
Buffalo Bills Gain Recognition Beyond Their Quarterback
Beyond Allen’s spotlight, the ESPN poll honored two other members of the Buffalo Bills roster. Running back James Cook made a strong leap to eighth overall, advancing from an honorable mention last season. Although Cook had only 50 carries during the previous season, his talent and potential caught the attention of evaluators, placing him just behind Christian McCaffrey, who took fifth place.
Offensive tackle Dion Dawkins also made his first appearance on the poll, ranked eighth at his position. An AFC executive praised Dawkins’ consistent performance and leadership, stating,
“Just very steady, stayed healthy, great leader. I’ve just always liked him—probably better football makeup than actual talent.”
—AFC Executive
These acknowledgments underline the Bills’ growing depth, spotlighting players who bring stability and leadership essential for a balanced team striving for NFL dominance.
Veteran Linebacker Von Miller Joins Washington Commanders
In a notable roster change, veteran linebacker Von Miller, a future Hall of Famer and former Buffalo Bill, has signed a one-year contract with the Washington Commanders. At 36 years old, Miller’s move to an NFC team comes with a $6.1 million deal. During his time with the Bills, he recorded 14 sacks over 36 games, demonstrating his continued value as a pass rusher and defensive presence.
Buffalo Bills’ Contract Considerations and Future Outlook
As the 2024 NFL season approaches, the Bills face critical decisions regarding contract extensions—most notably for James Cook. Retaining emerging talents like Cook will be vital as the team aims to convert Allen’s leadership and the growing roster potential into a championship run. The combination of seasoned stars and rising players sets Buffalo on a promising path toward challenging the NFL’s elite.