As the July 31 trade deadline approaches, Eugenio Suárez is poised to create an unprecedented moment in Major League Baseball history, with the New York Yankees emerging as frontrunners to acquire the power-hitting third baseman. Suárez’s outstanding 2025 campaign, leading the National League in home runs and RBIs, has ignited a fierce competition among contending teams.
Currently, Suárez tops the league with 35 home runs and 85 runs batted in, maintaining an impressive slash line of .257/.328/.601. His offensive output has only intensified since the All-Star break, highlighted by four home runs in just three games, prompting multiple teams to aggressively pursue his services.
Unprecedented Opportunity: Trading a 35-Home Run Hitter Midseason
MLB insider Bob Nightengale recently noted,
“No player in MLB history has been traded in-season after reaching 35 home runs. Diamondbacks All-Star third baseman Eugenio Suarez, who just hit his 35th homer, could very well be the 1st.”
— Bob Nightengale, MLB Insider
This statement underscores the rarity of Suárez’s situation, as no player with such prolific power has ever been dealt during the season.
This milestone performance places the Arizona Diamondbacks in a difficult position as they fight to remain in the postseason race. With a .500 record and trailing 4.5 games behind in the Wild Card standings, the team must weigh the merits of capitalizing on Suárez’s peak value or gambling on their October playoff chances.
The dilemma is clear: should Arizona sell at the height of Suárez’s market value or retain him in hopes of a late-season surge? Meanwhile, contenders like the Yankees see a perfect fit in Suárez, whose production could address their pressing lack of power at third base.
Yankees Eye Suárez to Address Critical Third Base Weakness
New York’s urgent need at third base is pressing. Following the recent release of DJ LeMahieu, the Yankees’ options have been limited, with players such as Oswald Peraza and Jorbit Vivas struggling at the plate with averages near .149. The team has even resorted to placing backup catchers in the hot corner during recent games.
General Manager Brian Cashman has promised an aggressive pursuit of talent ahead of the deadline, and Suárez fits the profile of an ideal rental. Earning $15 million this season and set to enter free agency after 2025, he provides power without long-term financial risk. Beyond New York, several other teams including the Seattle Mariners, Chicago Cubs, Detroit Tigers, Los Angeles Dodgers, and New York Mets have reportedly expressed interest.
Impact and Stakes for Arizona and MLB Trade Market
If the Diamondbacks choose to sell, Suárez would set a new benchmark as the first player to be traded midseason with 35 home runs already logged, surpassing previous transactions for rental players. His blistering pace—30 homers before the All-Star break and 20 since June 1—has made him arguably the most coveted position-player available. This situation illustrates a high-stakes decision for Arizona’s front office balancing competitiveness against long-term strategy.
Should Arizona retain Suárez, his bat could be the catalyst for a late-season push, potentially shifting the Wild Card landscape. Meanwhile, the Yankees’ pursuit exemplifies their commitment to strengthening a struggling infield and securing offensive firepower for the playoff stretch.