The St. Louis Cardinals are beginning trade discussions regarding third baseman Nolan Arenado as the MLB Trade Deadline approaches, despite his previous use of a no-trade clause to block a move to the Houston Astros. With the Cardinals trailing 8.5 games behind in the NL Central and 3.5 games out of the Wild Card race, they are exploring whether releasing Arenado could create new opportunities for the club’s future.
Cardinals’ Management Weighs Arenado’s Preferences and Trade Options
Cardinals general manager Mike Mozeliak has acknowledged that the team has yet to fully approach Arenado about a potential trade but intends to do so soon.
“I will. I haven’t, but that’s something we will have a good understanding of as we enter that final week [before the Trade Deadline],”
Mozeliak stated, indicating ongoing discussions to clarify Arenado’s stance. He also added,
“Right now, I would envision him being a part of this in the future, but if something were to pop up, I would definitely discuss it with him.”
These remarks reveal the Cardinals’ willingness to consider offers while remaining open to Arenado’s preferences.
Potential Benefits if Cardinals Trade Arenado from a Cub Fan Perspective
From the viewpoint of Chicago Cubs fans, the prospect of the Cardinals trading Arenado evokes mixed feelings. Those hoping for a trade focus primarily on this season’s dynamics. Optimism about Arenado sparking a Cardinals resurgence next year is low, so the focus shifts to how the market for Arenado might influence other roster moves.
For instance, if Arenado moves to a team that also targets third baseman Eugenio Suárez, his presence could indirectly benefit the Cubs’ chances of acquiring Suárez by reducing competition. This scenario gives Cubs supporters additional reasons to root for a successful Arenado trade, as it might open the door for their own acquisitions.
Concerns Over the Likelihood and Impact of an Arenado Trade
However, reservations exist about how likely and beneficial a trade would be. Even if Arenado joins another third-base-needy team, there remains a strong field of suitors for top batters this year. That assumption depends heavily on the Arizona Diamondbacks’ decisions, who currently hold players like Suárez and might change their approach if their performance improves.
More importantly, the Cardinals’ incentive to trade Arenado is connected to strengthening their long-term organizational health rather than immediate gains. Keeping Arenado does not appear to benefit their near-future plans. Some Cubs fans would prefer the Cardinals to fail in trading Arenado, forcing them to retain his contract through 2027 as his performance declines, which would limit the Cardinals’ salary flexibility and trade potential.
What Remains Ahead as Trade Deadline Draws Near
The Cardinals’ openness to exploring Nolan Arenado trade discussions signals a crucial crossroads for both the team and the broader MLB marketplace. Whether the Cardinals successfully move Arenado depends on his willingness and the offers presented during the last week before the trade deadline. For rival teams and fans alike, these developments may influence multiple roster moves and competition within the NL Central and beyond.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Is Nolan Arenado the best 3rd baseman ever?
A. Nolan Arenado will be remembered as a legendary third baseman. He is expected to be inducted into the Hall of Fame in Cooperstown someday. Only seven Major League Baseball players, including Arenado, have achieved over 350 home runs and more than 10 Gold Glove Awards. While Scott Rolen made it to the Hall of Fame, some believe that any third baseman better than average should have a chance. Rolen himself was considered more than just an above-average player.
Q. Has Nolan Arenado ever won a world series?
A. Before the 2021 season, the Cardinals traded for Arenado from the Rockies. Back then, he had been an All-Star three times, won two Gold Gloves, and came in third for the NL MVP in 2022. Despite this success, the Cardinals did not win any playoff series with him.