As the July 31 trade deadline approaches, the Los Angeles Dodgers are reportedly evaluating the potential trade of right-handed pitcher Dustin May. This development comes as Shohei Ohtani, the team’s standout two-way player, prepares to return to a starting rotation role, aiming for multiple innings per outing. The Dodgers’ management must balance Ohtani’s reintegration with roster decisions, including May’s uncertain future in Los Angeles.

Dustin May, a right-hander known for his power pitching, consistently throws fastballs approaching 97 to 98 mph and a sinker that has increased in velocity since his high school days. Despite these strengths, May’s 2025 season has been a mixed experience after he returned from a series of right elbow surgeries, including a Tommy John revision. His earned run average (ERA) stands at 4.73 over 17 starts with a 1.36 walks plus hits per inning pitched (WHIP), and his recent outings have raised concerns due to an elevated ERA around 6 in his last six appearances before this month.

On July 22, David Vassegh from AM 570 KLAC Dodgers Radio noted May’s potential departure, recalling,

“I saw Dustin May after the game last night, taking photos with his wife on the field. And you know, his name has come up in trade rumors. And that very well could have been the last time Dustin May pitched at Dodger Stadium wearing a Dodger uniform, because the trade deadline will be on July 31.”

—David Vassegh, Broadcaster

The uncertainty surrounding May’s role is heightened by the Dodgers’ efforts to reinforce their pitching staff as they aim for postseason success. Manager Dave Roberts addressed Ohtani’s readiness, stating,

“He’s on track to go four next time. I am assuming that comes in tomorrow, and the days after it feels good. I am not sure exactly what day we have got them scheduled, but it will be four innings.”

—Dave Roberts, Dodgers Manager

Ohtani’s gradual increase to pitching four innings per start reflects caution as the Dodgers prioritize his health and effectiveness. Meanwhile, the team is contemplating whether to retain May in the bullpen as a long-relief option or to explore trade opportunities before the deadline. The pressure mounts as the Dodgers seek to optimize their roster amid fluctuating performances and injury concerns.

Injury to Tanner Scott Heightens Bullpen Challenges for Dodgers

The Dodgers’ bullpen has recently suffered additional setbacks, most notably with the placement of left-hander Tanner Scott on the 15-day injured list due to left elbow discomfort. Scott’s absence removes a key late-inning contributor for a relief corps that already lacks the services of pitchers like Michael Kopech, Brusdar Graterol, and Ryan Phillips.

Scott is in the first season of a significant four-year, $72 million contract, has recorded 19 saves this season, but also carries the dubious mark of seven blown saves, tied for the highest in Major League Baseball. His 4.14 ERA underlines some inconsistency, but his presence remains integral to the Dodgers’ late-game plans.

The Dodgers promptly called up reliever Alexis Díaz from Triple-A Oklahoma City to fill Scott’s spot in the bullpen. General Manager Brandon Gomes acknowledged the challenge, remarking that Scott’s injury “hasn’t necessarily changed” the team’s approach but emphasized the need for additional bullpen reinforcements.

The severity of Scott’s elbow issues will be clearer once MRI results are available. If his injury proves more serious than inflammation, the Dodgers may be compelled to enter the trade market aggressively to secure experienced relief pitchers, a move that could reshape their bullpen strategy as the season enters its critical phase.

Balancing Trade Decisions With Bullpen Depth and Rotation Stability

The Dodgers find themselves at a crossroads, juggling the prospect of trading Dustin May while managing bullpen vulnerabilities exacerbated by Scott’s injury. May’s contract status and uneven performances make him a candidate for trade discussions, especially if the team can acquire bullpen assets or strengthen other areas ahead of the playoff push.

Meanwhile, Shohei Ohtani’s return to a four-inning starter role will bolster the starting rotation’s depth but creates a transitional period in how the Dodgers allocate pitching resources. Whether May will serve exclusively as a swingman through October or be dealt for more immediate bullpen help remains uncertain, yet the July 31 deadline imposes a firm timeline on these critical decisions.

This balancing act showcases the intense and complex decision-making required as the Dodgers strive to maintain both a competitive lineup and a resilient pitching staff. The path they choose could significantly influence their ability to contend late into the season and during the postseason.