Sidney Crosby’s future with the Pittsburgh Penguins is currently the center of intense discussion as the team navigates a challenging period following another missed playoff appearance in the 2024-25 NHL season. Trade rumors around Sidney Crosby Penguins trade rumors have intensified amid speculation that the veteran center might seek opportunities elsewhere before his contract ends in 2027.

Since being selected first overall in the 2005 NHL Draft by Pittsburgh, Crosby has been the defining figure for the Penguins, leading them to three Stanley Cup victories in 2009, 2016, and 2017. However, after a notably difficult season with a personal tally of 33 goals and 91 points in 80 games, questions about his commitment and future with the franchise are growing louder.

Experts weigh in on the possibility of Crosby being traded

Despite widespread speculation, several respected hockey insiders strongly doubt a mid-season trade involving Crosby is imminent. Veteran analyst John Shannon clearly stated on the Sekeres & Price podcast,

I do not see it, period,

—John Shannon, Hockey Analyst.

Frank Seravalli expressed a similar outlook, emphasizing Crosby’s own preferences:

I think ‘eventually’ might be the key word there. I could see it. I think it’s still a real long shot. Mostly because I think we’re taking Sidney Crosby — I think you have to take him at his own word. He wants to be a Pittsburgh Penguin. He wants to finish his career in Pittsburgh.

—Frank Seravalli, NHL Insider.

David Pagnotta also mentioned that while the Penguins are considering selling off players, Crosby remains a different case:

Pittsburgh, yeah they’re selling everybody, almost, no Crosby’s not getting traded; they’re willing to sell, but it’s a high price.

—David Pagnotta, Hockey Journalist.

On the other side, voices like Greg Wyshynski bring a different perspective. In an appearance on The Sheet with Jeff Marek, Wyshynski remarked,

I’ve long believed he will end his career in Montreal.

—Greg Wyshynski, Sports Writer. He suggested that if Pittsburgh continues to struggle, Crosby might seek a fresh start at a team he has a childhood affinity for, with Montreal standing out as a likely destination.

Jason Bukala echoed this sentiment, adding urgency to the issue:

He is going to age out of that roster (and) go win somewhere else, is what I think. And I think that’s one to keep an eye on.

—Jason Bukala, NHL Analyst.

Chris Johnston provided a more measured take, balancing the debate:

I’m still of the mind it’s more likely than not he doesn’t finish in Pittsburgh; but obviously he’s not there today or the trade would already have happened.

—Chris Johnston, NHL Reporter.

The mix of opinions illustrates the uncertainty surrounding Crosby’s next move. Fans and analysts alike are at a crossroads, wondering if the Penguins’ iconic captain will remain loyal amidst team turmoil or seek a final shot at glory elsewhere.

How Crosby’s future is connected to Evgeni Malkin’s status

One of the major factors influencing Crosby’s decision is the status of teammate Evgeni Malkin, his longtime partner on the ice. Both superstars share a strong bond that has lasted nearly two decades, highlighted by their three Stanley Cup championships together. Sidney Crosby’s commitment to Pittsburgh largely hinges on whether Malkin remains with the team.

Greg Wyshynski offered insight into the relationship dynamics, saying,

I’ve heard too many people that kind of know him and know that situation that tell me that’s he’s there as long as Geno’s there; if Geno’s there for one more year, then all bets are off as far as where Sid ends up.

—Greg Wyshynski, Sports Journalist.

Evgeni Malkin himself has expressed deep respect and admiration for Crosby and highlighted their remarkable connection:

I can say a lot about Crosby because we are together at practices, I see him in the locker room, I see how he works very hard, how he is dedicated to hockey. And all of his victories, all of his awards came to him through the sweat and very hard work. He is very talented, but the way he works on himself — I don’t think I have seen anyone who lives hockey like he does.

—Evgeni Malkin, Pittsburgh Penguins Forward.

Malkin’s own performance remains strong, having scored 50 points during the recent season with 16 goals and 34 assists over 68 games. He holds prominent records within the Penguins franchise, ranking second in games played (1,213), third in goals scored (514), assists (832), and total points (1,346). However, with Malkin’s contract expiring at the end of the 2025-26 season and no confirmed renewal, the upcoming year will be critical for both players’ futures with Pittsburgh.

The potential impact of Crosby’s decision on the Penguins and the NHL

Crosby’s choice on whether to stay put or seek a new team will profoundly influence the Penguins’ trajectory. As one of the most celebrated players in NHL history, his presence offers not just scoring prowess but leadership and morale boost for a team in transition. If Crosby opts to remain, it may stabilize Pittsburgh’s rebuilding efforts and provide young teammates with a veteran mentor to rally around.

Conversely, a move to another franchise could reshape several teams’ competitive outlooks, especially if Crosby aims to chase a final Stanley Cup championship elsewhere. Such a transfer would undeniably mark the close of an era in Pittsburgh and signal that the Penguins must accelerate their plans to rebuild without their cornerstone player.

For Crosby personally, this period represents a pivotal crossroads. After a storied career that includes multiple MVP awards and decades of excellence, deciding where to spend his twilight years in the league is both a personal and professional milestone. Whether he chooses loyalty to Pittsburgh or pursues fresh opportunities, the hockey world watches closely, eager to witness how the next chapter unfolds for one of the sport’s greatest stars.

Hope remains amid challenges for Crosby and the Penguins

Despite the uncertainty and anxious speculation, Crosby continues to deliver outstanding performances, maintaining impressive point-per-game statistics that reflect his undiminished skill and determination. His contract, which carries a cap hit of $8.7 million annually over the next two years, positions him as a valuable asset as an unrestricted free agent in 2027.

The Penguins face a significant challenge to balance their roster rebuild while respecting the legacy and influence Crosby holds within the organization. As the 2025-26 season approaches, much will hinge on the team’s decisions regarding Evgeni Malkin and how those moves are interpreted by Crosby.

For now, Sidney Crosby remains an emblem of hope for Pittsburgh fans, even as the franchise grapples with unanswered questions about their star player’s ultimate destination. The coming months will reveal whether his loyalty outlasts the difficult stretch or if a new chapter on another ice awaits the legendary captain.

Our Reader’s Queries

Q. How many teeth did Sidney Crosby lose?

A. Sidney Crosby lost two front teeth, yet his impressive goal made the Penguins happy. Despite the injury, Crosby couldn’t comment on the amazing one-handed goal he scored. This goal helped the Pittsburgh Penguins secure their 11th straight playoff spot.

Q. Did Sidney Crosby lose teeth?

A. Crosby broke his jaw and lost a few teeth, which meant he needed surgery on his jaw and significant dental treatment.

Q. What disease does Sidney Crosby have?

A. On Sunday, Dr. Dharmesh Vyas, the lead doctor for the Pittsburgh Penguins, held a news conference to discuss when Sidney Crosby was diagnosed with mumps.