Former MLB manager Joe Maddon has weighed in on the growing Anthony Volpe bench debate as the New York Yankees’ shortstop continues to struggle this season. Speaking Thursday on MLB Now, Maddon suggested the Yankees consider sending Volpe to the minors to regain his confidence and address defensive lapses witnessed in recent games.
Maddon highlighted a specific error Volpe made Wednesday night, taking a routine grounder at Rogers Centre, as an example of deeper issues.
“He got down on one knee … unsure of himself,”
Maddon said, identifying a lack of confidence beyond just difficult playing conditions.
“Something … his confidence is lacking right now.”
Statistical Decline Highlights Volpe’s Difficult Season
Despite Volpe’s previous Gold Glove-winning defense, recent numbers indicate his performance has dipped sharply. Defensive metrics such as Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) and Fielding Run Value (FRV) have tumbled from +10 DRS and +6 FRV last year to zero and +2 this season. Offensively, Volpe is struggling to contribute, currently hitting just .214 over 99 games with 12 home runs, 53 RBIs, and a .686 OPS, figures near the lower end of MLB shortstops.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone has stood firmly behind Volpe, but the statistics provide clear reasons for concern, supporting calls for a potential demotion to help the young shortstop reset his form and mindset.
Maddon Recommends a Temporary Demotion and Possible Shortstop Rental
Comparing Volpe’s situation to what the Mets recently did with top catcher prospect Francisco Alvarez—who returned stronger after a brief stint in the minors—Maddon advocates for a similar approach. He further suggested the Yankees pursue a shortstop rental at the trade deadline to reduce pressure on Volpe, who at just 24 still has room to develop but may not be ready to carry the team’s defensive responsibilities amid a championship window.
With Aaron Judge’s prime years ticking down and the team focused on winning now, Maddon implies that a tough choice must be made to avoid risking costly defensive mistakes. A temporary demotion, though difficult, could be necessary to safeguard the Yankees’ chances this season.