Each year in Cleveland, the pressing question remains unchanged: who will finally be the quarterback to end the cycle of disappointment? For Baker Mayfield, once the Browns’ prominent leader, that responsibility has lifted from his shoulders. Speaking on the New Heights podcast hosted by Travis and Jason Kelce, Mayfield dismissed the issue with a knowing grin.
Listen, I plead the fifth. When I was healthy, I was starting to get pretty damn good there.
—Baker Mayfield, Former Browns Quarterback
His comment reflects the emotional journey he endured—playing through injuries, breaking a long postseason drought, and then being unexpectedly replaced. Mayfield took pride in his time with Cleveland, recognizing what he helped achieve and giving fans hope, even though the momentum didn’t last.
Mayfield’s Legacy Amid Cleveland’s Current Quarterback Struggles
Mayfield spearheaded the Browns’ 2020 playoff upset over the Steelers, becoming a symbol of transformation. However, the team’s confidence waned after he battled a torn labrum in 2021. Following that, Cleveland pursued Deshaun Watson, a move that felt dismissive to Mayfield as the franchise never communicated with him before making the trade.
Meanwhile, Mayfield has found renewed success in Tampa Bay, rejuvenating his career with determination. In contrast, the Browns remain uncertain, still searching for a quarterback who will provide lasting stability.
Evaluating the Browns’ 2025 Quarterback Room Compared to Past Efforts
The Browns entered the 2025 training camp with a crowded quarterback roster including veteran Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett aiming to change his trajectory, and rookies Shedeur Sanders and Dillon Gabriel competing for recognition. Despite the numbers, a decisive leader has yet to emerge.
Mayfield’s remarks carry no bitterness, only a straightforward reflection from someone who gave their all but didn’t fit the front office’s vision. As Cleveland cycles through quarterbacks trying to solve their long-standing issue, Mayfield observes from the sidelines, steadily advancing his career while the Browns remain in search of answers.