Fantasy football managers are increasingly abandoning Jerry Jeudy amid growing concerns over his 2025 fantasy value risk, with trading data showing a steep decline in confidence. As Cleveland’s uncertain quarterback situation looms and Jeudy’s historical underperformance persists, fantasy owners appear eager to cut ties before his value drops further.

Rapid Decline in Confidence Surrounding Jerry Jeudy

The shift in fantasy managers’ attitudes toward Jeudy has accelerated sharply between June and July. In June, only 52.7% of trades involving Jeudy among PFSN users ended with him being traded away, but that figure surged to 69.6% in July, reflecting a sizable increase in roster drop-offs. This jump marks one of the most significant declines in player trust seen over the offseason, signaling broad skepticism about his fantasy relevance.

Many fantasy owners who once viewed Jeudy as a promising breakout candidate are now treating him as expendable. The sharp rise in trade-away rates indicates a growing consensus that Jeudy may no longer provide reliable fantasy production, especially given his move to the Browns and the uncertainty surrounding his new team’s offense.

Instability at Quarterback Jeopardizes Jeudy’s Outlook

Central to Jeudy’s diminished fantasy prospects is Cleveland’s unsettled quarterback position. As the 2025 season approaches, Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett, Dillon Gabriel, and Shedeur Sanders are all competing for the starting role, leaving Jeudy without a clear lead quarterback. This instability compounds concerns, given Jeudy’s track record of struggling to deliver fantasy value without strong QB play.

Examining Jeudy’s five-year NFL career, he has amassed only 15 touchdown receptions across 501 targets, equating to a low 3% touchdown rate that ranks poorly among receivers with comparable usage. Moreover, Jeudy has failed to meet preseason expectations in four of his five seasons, creating a pattern of underwhelming outputs that discourages fantasy owners.

While Jeudy improved during the 2024 campaign after Jameis Winston assumed the starting job, his surge may not be sustainable. From Week 8 onward, Jeudy averaged 21.1 PPR points per game—more than double his earlier 9.3-point average—alongside an increase to 10.6 targets per game. However, with Winston now signed by the New York Giants and no Cleveland quarterback boasting recent success supporting a top fantasy receiver, replicating last year’s performance appears unlikely.

Minimal Red Zone Presence Limits Upside

One of the most troubling aspects of Jeudy’s fantasy profile is his limited usage in the red zone, where touchdowns are most often scored. Despite running 712 routes and gaining 1,229 receiving yards last season, Jeudy touched the ball inside the 20-yard line only four times. This negligible involvement in scoring territory severely curtails his upside and frustrates managers seeking touchdown production.

To put this in perspective, Jeudy’s red zone routes account for less than 1% of his total opportunities, far below the 8-12% typical for elite fantasy receivers. This glaring disconnect from high-value fantasy situations suggests Jeudy’s role in his offense is predominantly focused on moving the chains rather than finishing drives.

Fantasy Managers Confront Tough Decisions on Jeudy

For fantasy owners holding onto Jeudy, the increasingly negative trade data and underlying performance metrics pose difficult choices. The market reaction is clear: patience is waning, and many managers are opting to move on in hopes of acquiring more consistent contributors. The 69.6% trade-away rate this July underscores widespread fears that waiting for Jeudy to rebound may not be a viable strategy.

Jeudy’s uncertain position in Cleveland, combined with a history of modest touchdown production and minimal red zone role, make his fantasy outlook bleak. While his route running and yardage accumulation may continue, the absence of a stable quarterback and red zone involvement likely restricts his ceiling. This reality check leaves many teams unwilling to risk roster spots on Jeudy, particularly those contending for championships.

The exodus from Jeudy may only accelerate as the new season nears, signaling that his days as a trusted fantasy asset could be over unless significant changes occur. For managers seeking reliability, moving Jeudy now may be the smartest play before his value declines further.