The Toronto Maple Leafs are reportedly considering a significant trade with the Pittsburgh Penguins that would bring winger Bryan Rust and forward Danton Heinen to Toronto. The proposed deal involves Toronto sending Bobby McMann, Calle Jarnkrok, Nicholas Robertson, a 2028 first-round pick, and a 2029 second-round pick to Pittsburgh, highlighting a potentially costly move for the team.
NHL insider Nick Alberga analyzed the trade scenario during The Leafs Nation’s Mock Trade Madness segment, noting that the asking price seems high primarily for Rust’s acquisition. While Heinen offers depth on a $4.5 million contract, he is not the focal point of the trade.
“That is a pretty hefty price tag to get pretty much essentially Bryan Rust unless you’re a big Danton Heinen guy.” Alberga said. —Nick Alberga, NHL Insider
Bryan Rust, who recorded 31 goals and 34 assists in 71 games during the 2024-25 season, is recognized for his speed and scoring prowess. Over the past six seasons, he has averaged about 25 goals annually and accumulated 203 goals in 638 NHL contests while maintaining a consistent top-six forward role. In comparison, Heinen contributed nine goals and 20 assists over 79 games last year, playing a solid two-way game mostly within a bottom-six role.
On the other side, the Maple Leafs would part with promising young talent: Bobby McMann had a productive season with 20 goals and 14 assists in 74 games; Nicholas Robertson continued his scoring development with 15 goals in 69 games; and Calle Jarnkrok, limited by injury to 19 games, totaled seven points. The inclusion of high-value draft picks further raises questions about whether the Leafs would be willing to sacrifice long-term potential for immediate lineup upgrades.
This trade proposal centers around strengthening Toronto’s forward lines by adding experienced players. Rust represents a scoring threat from the top six, while Heinen would provide additional depth and flexibility. However, the commitment to giving up young assets and future selections makes the deal appear unlikely at this time.
Prospects and Roster Decisions Ahead of the New Season
Meanwhile, Easton Cowan is aiming to secure a spot on the Maple Leafs’ roster for the 2025-26 campaign. Despite showing promise, there remains a possibility that he could begin the season with the AHL affiliate, the Toronto Marlies, depending on his performance during training camp evaluations.
“I have a chance to get a job, so that’s up to me to go out there and show what I can do and play my game,” Cowan said, via NHL.com. —Easton Cowan, Maple Leafs Prospect
Cowan is currently concentrating on building physical strength and enhancing his puck control skills to improve his chances of making the NHL lineup. The Leafs have available openings, which gives Cowan a tangible opportunity to prove himself.
“I’m just worried about myself,” Cowan said. “I have a chance to get a job, so that’s up to me to go out there.” —Easton Cowan, Maple Leafs Prospect
With the team balancing the potential acquisition of established forwards like Rust and Heinen against its young core and future draft capital, how the Maple Leafs manage their roster this offseason will be critical. The outcome of these decisions could have lasting effects on the team’s competitiveness in the upcoming seasons.