The San Francisco Giants recently revealed a ranked list of their top 50 franchise legends since moving to San Francisco, spotlighting players who made significant contributions through winning, impact, iconic moments, and enduring legacy. Compiled by Dave Tobener, this list honors the team’s most memorable figures while generating debate due to some unexpected placements, including rising star Logan Webb.
Barry Zito’s Complex Role in Giants History
One of the more debated figures on the list appears at No. 39, Barry Zito. After the Giants lost ace Jason Schmidt to free agency following the 2006 season, Zito arrived with high expectations rooted in his 2002 Cy Young Award. Despite carrying a large contract, Zito struggled for much of his tenure, posting only 2.6 bWAR over seven seasons. He was even left off the playoff roster in 2010, signaling a decline. However, his legacy was reshaped during the 2012 postseason when he pitched 7.2 scoreless innings in a critical NLCS game to stave off elimination and then delivered another strong outing in the World Series, solidifying his place in Giants lore despite ongoing debate about his overall impact.
Logan Webb’s Swift Rise to Elite Status
At No. 29, Logan Webb’s ranking on the Giants’ top 50 list impressively surpasses several franchise veterans. In just his fifth full season, Webb has established himself as the team’s ace with two All-Star selections and top-10 finishes in Cy Young voting, demonstrating both consistency and endurance by leading the league in innings pitched and posting a 5.6 bWAR. His emergence as a homegrown talent reflects the franchise’s hopes for sustained pitching excellence. Webb’s position ahead of notable pitchers like Jason Schmidt, who recorded 22.7 bWAR in six seasons with multiple All-Star nods and a World Series appearance, as well as Mike Krukow, praised for his 1986 campaign and lasting influence as a franchise figure, signals a turning point in Giants pitching leadership and legacy building.
Travis Ishikawa’s Moment to Remember Shines Bright
Perhaps the most surprising entry is Travis Ishikawa, ranked at No. 22, largely due to his unforgettable walk-off home run during the 2014 NLCS. This clutch hit sent the Giants to the World Series and remains an iconic highlight in franchise history. Ishikawa’s overall career with the Giants spanned parts of six seasons but was statistically modest, with just 17 home runs and a 94 OPS+ across 334 games, yielding a 1.5 bWAR. Despite limited performance metrics, his place on the list emphasizes how singular moments can shape a player’s legacy, especially when compared with perennial greats like Barry Bonds, Willie Mays, and Willie McCovey who also feature prominently.
Legacy, Passion, and the Future of Giants Franchise Rankings
This top 50 ranking encapsulates the Giants’ rich history by pairing widely recognized legends with surprising choices that provoke conversation among fans and analysts alike. The inclusion of players like Logan Webb highlights the franchise’s focus on current and future leadership while honoring historic achievements. As this list continues to be discussed, it underscores the deep passion and pride inherent in following one of baseball’s most storied teams, suggesting that debates over player legacies will persist as new stars emerge and the franchise evolves.
Our Reader’s Queries
Q. Is Logan Webb legally blind?
A. During high school, he was the main quarterback for two years. He is legally blind due to astigmatism, leading to blurry vision.
He discovered this vision problem in third or fourth grade when he couldn’t see the ball clearly. He wore glasses until he was 11 or 12, which made playing football harder.
Q. Is Logan Webb a dad?
A. Webb is the main pitcher who is helping the Giants stay in the playoff competition. His growth as an athlete, individual, and team player, as well as his new role as a father to a daughter, contribute to his achievements in 2025.