Scottie Scheffler, who has rapidly risen in the world of golf, came under intense scrutiny regarding his potential to match the Tiger Woods major record during the 2025 Masters Golf Tournament in Augusta. While Scheffler’s ascent has drawn comparisons to Woods, questions about the sustainability of his dominance and his capacity to accumulate double-digit major wins have divided analysts and insiders alike.
Despite sharing the same time span of 1,197 days to reach four major victories as Woods did, some voices suggest that Scheffler’s trajectory may not continue upward. The golf community is now closely watching whether he will become one of the sport’s all-time greats or face setbacks that prevent him from reaching Tiger Woods’ legendary status.
Concerns Raised Over Scheffler’s Technique and Longevity
Mark Allen, a commentator on the Talk To Me Birdie podcast, articulated a notable skepticism about Scheffler’s long-term success. He expressed doubt about Scheffler’s ability to win as many majors as many predict. Allen’s critique focuses heavily on Scheffler’s footwork, an aspect of his swing that appears inconsistent under pressure.
“I’m going to regret what I’m about to say. I don’t think he’s going to win as many as most think he’s going to win,”
—Mark Allen, Golf Analyst
Allen highlighted footage from the 2025 U.S. Open at Oakmont where Scheffler’s lower body movement seemed unsteady, signaling potential technical flaws. Unlike the steady footwork he admires in Rory McIlroy, Allen described Scheffler’s movement as erratic and similar to that of a casual weekend player. This, he argues, might eventually affect his consistency and success.
“At some point, he’s got to start missing the center of the club,”
—Mark Allen, Golf Analyst
“I look at Rory McIlroy’s footwork, then I look at his… and I think, my god, it’s like a complete weekend warrior hacker,”
—Mark Allen, Golf Analyst
Allen also emphasized that while many predict Scheffler could win ten or more majors, he remains unconvinced that his footwork technique will support such a record. He reinforced this point with a comparison to established greats of the game.
“People are talking about Tiger at the moment. Tiger won 15. I don’t think he’ll get to double figures,”
—Mark Allen, Golf Analyst
Allen referenced historical players like Ernie Els and Ben Hogan, who, despite their dominance and consistent contention, fell short of reaching double-digit major victories. His perspective suggests that Scheffler’s eventual ceiling might lie below these all-time greats.
Competitors and Analysts Differ on Scheffler’s Future Prospects
Scottie Scheffler’s achievements have earned respect even from tough competitors such as Xander Schauffele and Rory McIlroy, who recognize his sustained excellence over the past several years. Schauffele described Scheffler’s play as extraordinary for more than two years straight.
“You can’t even say he’s on a run. He’s just been killing it for over two years now,”
—Xander Schauffele, Professional Golfer
Similarly, McIlroy noted that few golfers in history have maintained such consistent elite performance, underscoring the high regard they hold for Scheffler’s recent form.
However, some voices challenge Allen’s more critical position. Nick O’Hern, co-host of the podcast, argued that Scheffler’s age and remaining career span offer ample opportunity to add significant achievements to his record.
“He might at 35 pack it up… He gets 10 more years; that’s 40 majors,”
—Nick O’Hern, Podcast Co-host
O’Hern’s point reflects the view that judging the ceiling of a 29-year-old player may be premature considering the typical longevity of top golfers.
Supporters Believe Scheffler’s Game is Built for Enduring Success
On the more optimistic side, golf analyst Ryan Lavner sees Scheffler as a player whose talent and mindset indicate sustained success rather than a passing hot streak. Lavner emphasizes Scheffler’s fundamentals, mental calmness, and adaptability under pressure as crucial factors that support a long and fruitful career.
Lavner has projected that Scheffler could reach around ten major titles, a figure that places him among golf’s elite.
This prediction is contingent upon factors like maintaining physical health and motivation, but Lavner’s confidence reflects a belief that Scheffler’s winning style is built to last.
Implications for the Future of Golf’s Greatest Achievements
The ongoing discussion about Scottie Scheffler’s ability to match or surpass Tiger Woods major record comparison highlights the high stakes and speculation surrounding the current generation of golfers. Scheffler’s performance in upcoming majors will be key in determining whether he can maintain his form, evolve technically, and join the sport’s pantheon of legends.
While Mark Allen’s doubts introduce caution and remind fans of the fragility behind athletic dominance, supporters like Ryan Lavner and Scheffler’s peers offer a counterbalance, optimistic that the young golfer’s trajectory will continue upward. Regardless of the outcome, Scheffler’s career will be closely watched as golf enthusiasts await how his legacy unfolds in relation to Woods and other greats.