Luis Robert Jr. has been seen as an ideal fit to strengthen the Cincinnati Reds’ outfield, offering controlled power despite inconsistent production. Coming off a disappointing 2024 season, Robert became a focal point of trade discussions. His struggles have continued into 2025, but the involvement of other contenders, especially the New York Mets, may drive up the White Sox’s demands beyond what the Reds can offer.

The Mets appear to be serious suitors, reportedly setting a high standard for a trade. According to USA Today’s Bob Nightengale, the White Sox have requested third baseman Mark Vientos in exchange for Robert. Although Vientos is having a down year, he had a strong performance in 2024 and remains under team control without arbitration, making him a valuable asset. For a Reds team focused on preserving its young talent, this price may be too steep.

Mets’ involvement could inflate the trade cost beyond Reds’ reach

The White Sox initially hoped for prospects but may now prioritize acquiring established major leaguers, with the Mets potentially willing to offer Mark Vientos. The Mets have plans to fill the third base position with Brett Baty, who is improving defensively, and rookie Ronny Mauricio. They might even orchestrate a three-team trade to secure Robert along with a third baseman like Eugenio Suárez.

In contrast, the Reds lack the roster depth and trade leverage to match such proposals. Although Cincinnati possesses major league players who could be offered instead of Vientos—such as Christian Encarnacion-Strand currently in Triple-A, paired with a prospect—these options come with risks. Other controllable players like Tyler Stephenson and Matt McLain would create lineup gaps that the Reds may not be ready to fill, especially without a player like Jonathan India on the roster.

Cincinnati’s ongoing outfield struggles highlight challenges in acquiring Robert

Despite a recent surge in performance, the Reds continue to struggle offensively with right-handed hitters ranking in the lower third of the league. The often-injured Robert might not be the solution if obtaining him requires sacrificing key players vital to the team’s future. Alternatives like Taylor Ward or Ramón Laureano could be more attainable and cost-effective for Cincinnati’s roster needs, offering upgrades without demanding major assets.

“The White Sox have asked for third baseman Mark Vientos in exchange for Robert.” —Bob Nightengale, USA Today