Toronto Maple Leafs captain Auston Matthews struggled last season, affected by a lingering injury that sidelined him for 15 regular-season games. Despite scoring 33 goals, this was his lowest tally in nine years, a sharp decline from the 69 goals he netted in the 2023-24 season. The injury, which did not require surgery, impacted his performance significantly, with treatment sought in Germany under his trusted doctor’s care. Matthews admitted the injury influenced many aspects of his game.

With Mitch Marner traded to the Vegas Golden Knights, questions arise about how Matthews will perform without his longtime linemate. Marner, who posted 102 points last season and 13 in the playoffs, was a crucial offensive contributor. The Leafs acquired forward Nicolas Roy in return, but the loss of Marner’s playmaking ability leaves a considerable void.

Expert Views on Matthews’ Capacity to Lead the Team

Former NHL player Jay Rosehill discussed Matthews’ situation on the Leafs Morning Take podcast. Rosehill emphasized Matthews’ role as the team’s captain and best player, describing him as the one capable of carrying the Maple Leafs forward if at his best. However, Rosehill expressed concerns about Matthews’ form last season, noting that his injury hindered him from playing at his usual high level.

“Yeah, he’s the captain of the team,” Rosehill said. “He’s the best player on the team. He’s the one who can pull the team. He’s one of a few guys who can single-handedly win again. If he’s playing his best hockey. There’s not much stop in you, and I just didn’t see it last year. I didn’t think he was capable of doing that, very often, and you could tell he wasn’t himself.”

Matthews remains confident that the time off during the offseason will aid his recovery and help him regain his peak form. He acknowledged there were periods last year when he did not feel well on the ice.

“There were some stretches where I didn’t feel very good,” Matthews said, via NHL.com.

Marner’s Move to Vegas and Its Impact on the Leafs

Mitch Marner, formerly Matthews’ linemate, recently signed an eight-year, $96 million deal following his trade to Vegas. Marner explained that his decision was driven by a desire to join a team with strong championship prospects.

“You want to be in a place where you want to win,” Marner said, via NHL.com. “That’s the whole goal of why we do this … This team, since it’s entered the League, has really pushed the boundaries to be that winning team, that’s where I want to be.”

For the Maple Leafs, filling the void left by Marner will be key to their success. Players like Matthew Knies, who recently committed to a six-year, $46.5 million contract, remain important core contributors. The responsibility falls on coach Craig Berube to adjust the team’s lines during training camp to find the best chemistry without Marner.

Looking Ahead: The Maple Leafs’ Test Without Marner

The Toronto Maple Leafs’ upcoming season hinges on how well Auston Matthews adapts to playing without Mitch Marner. Matthews’ ability to recover fully from injury and elevate his game will be critical if the team hopes to contend for the Hart Trophy and maintain a strong position in the NHL. The reshuffled lineup and coaching strategies will also play vital roles in navigating this significant transition.