The race for the Indianapolis Colts’ starting quarterback job this summer has drawn close attention, especially as Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones compete for the role. The ongoing competition at quarterback raises questions about whether the Colts have found their long-term leader on the roster. The focus on the Anthony Richardson Colts QB competition has increased following early impressions at training camp, where both players have showcased different traits.
Insights from a Former Colts Coach on Quarterback Performances
Rick Venturi, a former Colts coach and current radio analyst, shared his observations on Richardson and Jones during the initial days of the Colts’ training camp. Venturi highlighted that while Daniel Jones performs consistently, he does not produce moments of exceptional excitement. In contrast, Richardson’s style can deliver a higher level of enthusiasm.
“He’s never gonna wow you,” Venturi said about Jones. “You’re never gonna walk out of here going, ‘Oh, my God, yeah.’ But he does everything pretty well, and he’s a much better athlete than people give him credit for. Now, Richardson? He gives you more, ‘Wow,’ and I think if it remains close, they’ll go with him.”
Venturi’s assessment suggests that Jones offers reliability, but Richardson’s dynamic play may tip the scales if the competition stays tight.
Comparing Past Performances of Richardson and Jones
Daniel Jones had a strong 2022 season with the New York Giants, contributing to their playoff run and earning a postseason road victory. Pro Football Reference ranks him sixth among qualified NFL players with a 62.9 adjusted QBR that year. However, Jones struggled more recently, finishing with a 3-13 record in his last 16 starts before the Giants released him in November 2024.
Meanwhile, Anthony Richardson has faced notable challenges in his early career. Completing just 47.7 percent of his passes in 2024, Richardson ranked last among qualifying quarterbacks, with a passer rating of 61.6. Injuries and a two-game benching limited the 2023 first-round pick to only 15 starts over his first two seasons. Despite this, Richardson has shown potential during offseason workouts and training camp.
Progress and Areas Needing Improvement for Richardson
Venturi pointed out that Richardson still needs to improve on making routine throws expected of starting quarterbacks, describing these as “layup” passes defenses often exploit. Nevertheless, the 23-year-old has demonstrated progress this summer, showing sharper decision-making and more confident throws in practice and drills.
“Every time he throws a ball that looks decisive, you’re happy with it,”
Venturi added.
“This week, he’s done that better than I’ve seen him do it in a long time.”
This development has generated optimism about Richardson’s ability to claim the starting role, especially if his performance continues on an upward trajectory.
Preseason Betting Odds Reflect Confidence in Richardson
As of early August, FanDuel Sportsbook lists Richardson as the -350 favorite over Jones (+255) to start the Colts’ Week 1 game against the Miami Dolphins. This betting trend emphasizes the growing belief in Richardson within the fanbase and betting markets. Observers will closely watch both quarterbacks’ performances in the Colts’ preseason opener against the Baltimore Ravens on August 7 to gauge how the competition might unfold.
What This Quarterback Battle Means for the Colts’ Future
The Colts’ quarterback competition serves as a pivotal moment for the franchise as it searches for stability and growth at a key position. While Jones offers experience and steady play, Richardson provides athleticism and a flashier style that could energize the offense. The team’s decision, influenced by summer camp developments and preseason games, will likely shape the Colts’ trajectory for the 2024 season and beyond. Fans and analysts alike await the official starter announcement, recognizing that this decision will carry significant implications for the Colts’ offense and postseason hopes.